/
Login
Breaking
All news
Comparator

Futures firms comparator

Pick two prop firms and see them side by side: rules, plans, platforms, leverage, commissions and payouts, next to each one's discount.

  • Field by field, side by side
  • Only the differences in one click
  • Link to the written comparison
Read the comparison
Head to head

52 differences

Headquarters

Paris

30 North Gould Street, Ste R
City: Sheridan
State: Wyoming (WY)
Postal code: 82801

CEO

Léon Grimm

Matt Morris

Country

France

United States

Foundation

2023

2024

Banned Countries
Afghanistan, Armenia, Belarus, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Burma (Myanmar), Burundi, Central African Republic, Cuba, Egypt, Eritrea, Ethiopia (certain sectors), Georgia (specific territories), Guinea, Haiti, Iran, Iraq, Ivory Coast, Kosovo, Lebanon, Libya, Mali, Nicaragua, North Korea, Russia, Somalia, South Sudan, Sudan, Syria, Tunisia, Turkey, Ukraine (Crimea, Donetsk, Luhansk, Kherson, Zaporizhzhia), Venezuela, Yemen, Zimbabwe
Afghanistan, Albania, Algeria, Angola, Antigua and Barbuda, Azerbaijan, Bahamas, Bangladesh, Belarus, Benin, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Botswana, Bulgaria, Burkina Faso, Burundi, Cambodia, Cameroon, Central African Republic, Chad, China, Congo, Croatia, Cuba, DR Congo, Djibouti, Egypt, Equatorial Guinea, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Gabon, Gambia, Ghana, Guinea, Guinea-Bissau, Haiti, Indonesia, Iran, Iraq, Ivory Coast, Jamaica, Kenya, Kosovo, Kyrgyzstan, Laos, Lebanon, Lesotho, Liberia, Libya, Madagascar, Malawi, Malaysia, Mali, Mauritania, Montenegro, Morocco, Mozambique, Myanmar, Namibia, Nicaragua, Niger, Nigeria, North Korea, North Macedonia, Pakistan, Philippines, Romania, Russia, Rwanda, Senegal, Serbia, Sierra Leone, Slovenia, Somalia, South Africa, South Sudan, Sudan, Swaziland, Syria, Tajikistan, Tanzania, Togo, Tunisia, Turkey, Turkmenistan, Uganda, Ukraine, Uzbekistan, Venezuela, Vietnam, Yemen, Zambia, Zimbabwe
Assets
Indices, Currencies, Metals, Energies, Agriculture, Interest Rates, Crypto
Futures
Brokers
TFeed, dxFeed, Rithmic, Edge Clear
Project X
Payout Fee

Merit Live: Phoenix covers the processor fee on withdrawals above $500.

No data
Platforms
Odin, Quantower, ATAS, Volumetrica, DeepCharts, DeepDOM, NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView, Sierra Chart, MultiCharts, Jigsaw, Bookmap, MotiveWave, Investor/RT, Tiger.Trade, Overcharts, Volfix, Optimus Flow, Photon, Inside Edge Trader, QScalp, Agena Trader
Project X, Quantower, Black Arrow, WealthCharts
Payout Methods
Payoneer, Wise, PayPal
Rise, Crypto, Transfer
Live Account
Yes

Live Funded account at EdgeClear on Rithmic. Classic and Spark: after 4 payouts. Daily: once $1,200/$3,000/$6,000 has been paid (Seed/Starter/Growth). Merit: straight to Live on approval. Risk review required; if not passed, the pre-funded payout limit may be extended instead. Live amount: Classic $1,250/$2,000/$3,500; Spark $400/$1,000; Daily $500/$1,250/$2,000; Merit $2,000. Static drawdown, daily limit agreed with the trader, and every rule waived except overnight and over-week positions. Other funded accounts go dormant on transfer.

Yes

Transition to Live
After 3 successful payouts, a risk manager will evaluate your account and decide whether you continue in INSTANT or move to Live (the transition may occur before the third payout).

During the transition:

  • All other accounts are paused or closed
  • Only 1 Live account is allowed
  • Trading on SIM accounts is not allowed while the review is ongoing

Pre-Live Stage
Pre-Live is an intermediate phase created to facilitate the move from SIM to real capital and to evaluate discipline and risk management under conditions close to Live:

  • 1 daily payout from the first day in profit
  • No consistency rule
  • No maximum withdrawal limits
  • Activation in 3–5 days

Move to Full Live
After demonstrating consistency in Pre-Live, the account is upgraded to Live (Plus500) with real capital, without restarting the process or affecting payouts:

  • Up to 10% of the initial balance of the SIM account is transferred
  • Only one account migrates to Live
  • The highest profit from a single account is transferred
Payment Methods
Card, Crypto
Card, Crypto
Payout Frequency

Classic: weekly, first payout after 5 trading days and then every 5. Spark: bi-weekly, first payout after 5 trading days. Daily: any trading day once profit matures (3 trading days; 5 for a day above 30% of total profit and above the tier's daily cap). Merit Live: any time, up to 10 per day. Processing: 2 to 3 business days.

Elite Challenge / Elite Sim Funded

  • Profit target per payout cycle: 6% (1st) / 5% (2nd) / 4% (3rd onward)
  • Consistency resets after each payout

Elite Daily (Funded)

  • Daily payouts starting from day 1
  • Must reach buffer + $500 minimum

Elite ACCESS (Funded)

  • On-demand payouts (any time after meeting requirements)
  • Min 5 profitable days (per size: 25k=$200, 50k=$250, 100k=$300, 150k=$350)

Instant Sim Funded

  • Profit target per payout cycle: 6% (1st) / 5% (2nd) / 4% (3rd onward)
  • Consistency rule 20%

S2F Sim Pro

  • Min 10 trading days, at least 7 profitable (profitable day = 0.1% of starting balance)
  • Profit target per cycle: 6% / 5% / 4%
  • ESS 20% or less

IGNITE

  • 5% profit target each payout (resets after every payout cycle)
  • No minimum trading days

X-ULTRA

  • 7 profitable days before each payout; 4 with the paid add-on
  • Minimum closing profit for a day to count: 50K $250 / 100K $500 / 150K $750
  • New qualifying days required after each payout
Maximum Withdrawal

Per payout: Classic $600/$1,000/$2,000 (Starter/Growth/Scale); Spark $300/$400 (Seed/Starter). Daily: $200/$500/$1,000 per trading day (Seed/Starter/Growth), with $1,000 per day per trader across all Daily accounts. Merit Live: no maximum. PayPal: $2,000 per month.

Maximum payout per withdrawal before moving to Live. No cap applies after moving to Live.

ELITE and S2F Sim Pro

Account Size Max Payout Per Withdrawal
$25,000 $1,500
$50,000 $2,500
$100,000 $3,000
$150,000 $3,500

INSTANT Sim Funded, purchased before 7/27/2026

Account Size Max Payout Per Withdrawal
$25,000 $1,500
$50,000 $2,500
$100,000 $3,000
$150,000 $3,500

INSTANT Sim Funded 2.0, purchased on or after 7/27/2026

Account Size Max Payout Per Withdrawal
$25,000 $1,000
$50,000 $2,000
$100,000 $2,500
$150,000 $3,000

IGNITE

Account Size Max Payout Per Withdrawal
$25,000 $500
$50,000 $1,000
$100,000 $1,500

X-ULTRA

Account Size Max Payout Per Withdrawal
$50,000 $5,000
$100,000 $7,000
$150,000 $9,000
Minimum Withdrawal

Classic and Daily: $75. Spark: $30 (Seed) or $75 (Starter). Merit Live: $1.

  • IGNITE: $250
  • Elite Daily / Elite ACCESS / Instant / S2F / Elite Challenge: $500
  • X-ULTRA: $50
Other Payout Requirements

After passing: review of up to 72 hours, then KYC and Pre-Funded contract within 48 hours. The trailing drawdown locks at the starting balance on the first payout. Every denied payout comes with a written reason from the risk team. No crypto payouts.

X-ULTRA: at least 50% of each payout request must come from new profit earned since the previous payout. No payout buffer.

Payout Guarantee
No data

Less than 12 hours on average from request to payment. Average support response time: under 60 seconds via 24/7 live chat.

Commission

Per contract and side on TFeed; dxFeed is double. ES, NQ, RTY and YM $1.09; MES, MNQ, M2K and MYM $0.35; CL $1.15; MCL $0.43; GC $1.20; MGC $0.43; NG $1.20; 6E $1.20; ZN $0.80; ZB $0.83; BTC $3.38; MBT $1.38. Same rates on every line, in evaluation and funded.

No data
Account Reset

Classic, Daily and Spark: unlimited, by paying the fee or with reset coupons (one per month the challenge stays alive; they stack and never expire). Classic: a failed account is reset free at renewal. Merit: no reset.

Elite Challenge (challenge)

  • $25K: $29
  • $50K: $39
  • $100K: $79
  • $150K: $119

Elite Sim Funded (funded reset)

  • $25K: $199
  • $50K: $299
  • $100K: $399
  • $150K: $499

Elite Daily (challenge)

  • $25K: $79
  • $50K: $99
  • $100K: $189
  • $150K: $265

Elite Daily (funded)

  • $25K: $299
  • $50K: $499
  • $100K: $849
  • $150K: $849 (V1); V2 confirm pending

Elite ACCESS (challenge)

  • $35 flat (all sizes)

Elite ACCESS (funded)

  • $25K: $299
  • $50K: $499
  • $100K: $849
  • $150K: $1,349

Instant / S2F Sim Pro / IGNITE

  • No reset option

X-ULTRA

  • Paid evaluation resets remain available after new accounts sell out. Each reset starts a new 30-day evaluation period.
Add-ons
Yes

Performance Review (+20% on the price): 20 to 30 page report on the trader's own trades. Free ATAS licence with dxFeed.

Yes

X-ULTRA: 4 profitable days before each payout instead of 7 (+30%).

Instant
No
Yes
One Step
Yes
Yes
Account scaling
Limited

Scaling beyond the Classic plan on request, after a full review of the trades.

No
Max Drawdown

Classic and Daily: end-of-day trailing in evaluation and funded. Spark: end-of-day trailing in evaluation and real-time trailing once funded. The trailing drawdown locks at the starting balance. Merit: static, the whole $2,000 balance. Live: static.

EOD trailing drawdown: Elite Challenge, Elite Daily, Elite ACCESS Standard, Instant Sim Funded and IGNITE.

Elite ACCESS Intraday uses EOD trailing drawdown during evaluation and real-time intraday trailing drawdown when funded. The funded drawdown follows the highest realized or unrealized equity and locks at starting balance + $100 after the first payout.

S2F Sim Pro uses intraday trailing drawdown.

For Instant Sim Funded, the trailing drawdown locks above the starting balance once its lock condition is reached or after the first payout.

X-ULTRA
EOD trailing in evaluation and funded stages; follows the highest closing balance, never moves down and locks at starting balance + $100. Falling below the threshold fails the account. Funded drawdown: $3,000 / $4,500 / $6,000 for 50K / 100K / 150K.

Profit Split

Classic and Spark: 90%. Daily: 80%. Merit: 50% until the trader has withdrawn twice the starting balance, then 80%.

All products: 90/10 (trader keeps 90%).

  • Elite Challenge / Elite Daily / Elite ACCESS
  • Instant Sim Funded
  • S2F Sim Pro
  • IGNITE
Daily Drawdown

Classic, Daily and Spark: none. Merit: 25% dynamic (soft breach). Live: agreed with each trader based on their results.

Elite Challenge

  • 2.5% (EOD soft breach)

Elite Daily

  • $25K: 2% ($500)
  • $50K: 2% ($1,000)
  • $100K: 1.25% ($1,250)
  • $150K: 1% ($1,500)
  • V2 (5/11/26 onward, evaluation and funded): same as V1

Elite ACCESS

  • Evaluation: none
  • Funded: $25K $500 / $50K $1,000 / $100K $1,250 / $150K $1,750

Instant Sim Funded

  • 2.5% ($625 / $1,250 / $2,500 / $3,750)

S2F Sim Pro

  • 2% intraday ($500 / $1,000 / $2,000 / $3,000)

IGNITE

  • 2% ($500 / $1,000 / $2,000 / $3,000)

X-ULTRA

  • Hard breach in evaluation and funded accounts, measured from the starting balance for the day. Includes closed and floating losses, commissions and fees. Resets at 6:00 PM ET.
Max Allocation
700,000

Accounts per trader or household:

  • 5 ELITE (Elite Challenge / Elite Sim Funded)
  • 5 ELITE DAILY
  • 5 ELITE ACCESS
  • 5 INSTANT Sim Funded
  • 5 S2F Sim Pro (more during special promotions)
  • 10 IGNITE (same size, for copy trading)

Purchasing limits (Elite / Elite Daily / Elite ACCESS)

  • 10 evaluation accounts per rolling 30-day window
  • 12 resets per 30-day window
  • Max 5 active funded accounts at any time

X-ULTRA

  • Maximum 3 X-ULTRA accounts at the same time
Mandatory buffer
Limited

Classic and Daily: a locked buffer equal to the maximum drawdown stays in the account and is not withdrawable. Spark and Merit: none.

No
Maximum Accounts

Unlimited challenges. Pre-funded: 5 on TFeed (up to 3 Spark, 3 Daily, 3 Classic Growth or Scale and 5 Classic Starter) and 3 on dxFeed. Live: up to 5, at Phoenix's discretion. Merit: one attempt; another requires buying a Classic or Daily account first.

No data
Maximum Trading Days

No deadline. Spark closes after 90 days without a trade. Merit: 30 calendar days.

Elite ACCESS (evaluation)

  • 30 days to pass

Elite Challenge / Elite Daily / Instant / S2F / IGNITE

  • No time limit

X-ULTRA (evaluation)

  • 30 days to pass; a purchased reset starts a new 30-day period
Minimum Trading Days

Classic and Daily: 2. Spark: 1. Merit: none; the challenge lasts 30 calendar days.

Elite Challenge

  • None (can pass in 1 day)

Elite ACCESS

  • 1 day minimum to pass evaluation

Elite Daily (Funded)

  • 1 day (for payout eligibility)

S2F Sim Pro

  • 10 trading days, at least 7 profitable (profitable day = 0.1% of starting balance)

Instant Sim Funded / IGNITE

  • None

X-ULTRA (evaluation)

  • No minimum trading days.
Funded Phase Pricing Model

No monthly fee on funded accounts. Activation: $29 one-time on Spark; $0 on Classic, Daily and Merit. Live: CME professional data at $135/month per exchange, deducted from the account.

Elite Challenge: one-time activation fee after passing.

Elite ACCESS Standard activation: $139 / $189 / $259 / $359 for 25K / 50K / 100K / 150K.

Elite ACCESS Intraday activation: $69 / $94 / $129 / $179.

Elite Daily, Instant Sim Funded, S2F Sim Pro and IGNITE: no activation fee.

Points Reward Program

Phoenix Extra: PHX earned for ideas and ambassador work, usable on accounts, resets and activation fees. Not convertible to cash.

No data
Minimum Profitable Days

Classic: 5 days between payouts with at least $100/$200/$300 profit (Starter/Growth/Scale). Spark: 5 days with at least $40 (Seed) or $100 (Starter). Daily and Merit: none.

Elite ACCESS (Funded)

  • 5 profitable days required before first payout
  • Min daily profit: $25K $200 / $50K $250 / $100K $300 / $150K $350

S2F Sim Pro

  • 7 profitable days out of 10 trading days
  • Profitable day = 0.1% of starting balance

Elite Daily / Instant Sim Funded / IGNITE / Elite Challenge

  • No minimum profitable days requirement (consistency targets only)
Position size scaling
Limited

Classic: the contract limit rises with profit at $1,000, $2,000 and $4,000 up to the account maximum, in evaluation and funded, and drops if profit falls back. Spark, Daily and Merit: full size from day one. Live: one extra mini per $2,000 of profit.

Limited

X-ULTRA funded accounts: contract limits adjust daily using closing profit, increasing or decreasing with the applicable level. Payouts can reduce the level. No scaling during evaluation.

Evaluation Phase Pricing Model

Classic: monthly subscription every 30 days, cancelled automatically on passing; dxFeed adds $20/month. Daily, Spark and Merit: one-time payment. No refunds.

Elite Challenge and Elite Daily: monthly subscription.

Elite ACCESS Standard and Intraday: $39 one-time entry fee; a one-time activation fee applies after passing.

Instant Sim Funded, S2F Sim Pro and IGNITE: one-time fee.

Free Trial
No data
Limited

Receive a practice account when you purchase a paid

Merge Accounts
No data
No
Consistency Rule
No data
Yes

Per-product consistency targets

  • Elite Sim Funded: 25% (best day / total profit)
  • Elite Daily (evaluation only): 45% V1 / 40% V2 (accounts from 5/11/26)
  • Elite ACCESS (Funded): 40%
  • Instant Sim Funded: 20%
  • S2F Sim Pro: 20% Equity Stability Score (ESS), not a consistency rule per se
  • IGNITE: 15%

Consistency / ESS resets after each payout cycle.

  • X-ULTRA: 50% during evaluation (best day / total profit); none when funded.
Expert Advisor (EA)
No

HFT and bots that trade without the trader are prohibited. Tools that assist the trader (hotkeys, DOM, alerts) are allowed.

No

EAs and bots are NOT allowed on any account type. Manual trading only. Violations may lead to account suspension, termination or loss of funding privileges.

VPN
Yes

VPN, VPS and proxy allowed; sessions are monitored and identity documents may be requested.

Limited

Not advised. Must notify or your account might be breached.

Allowed

  • Trading from different devices (mobile, desktop)
  • VPS with static IP (must notify support in advance and provide the invoice)
  • Traveling and trading (may require documentation)

Not Allowed

  • Using multiple IPs on the same account frequently
  • Trading multiple accounts from the same IP
  • Using a VPN (strictly prohibited)
Hedging
No

Opposite positions on the same asset across accounts, own or someone else's.

No data
Scalping
Yes

No minimum trade duration.

Yes

Scalping allowed, with one restriction:

10-second rule (all account types)

  • All trades must remain open longer than 10 seconds
  • 10.00 seconds = violation; 10.01 seconds = acceptable
  • Closing any portion of a trade before 10 seconds violates the rule
  • Adding to a trade (scaling in) within 10 seconds is permitted
  • Occasional minor violations are tolerated; if ~50% or more of profits/trades violate this rule, profits are removed
Stacking / Layering (DCA)
No

Rotating through accounts, each risked in full on the same bet until one hits, is prohibited. Holding several accounts is allowed.

Yes
Martingale
Limited

Allowed within a single account, also DCA. Prohibited across accounts.

No data
Copy Trading
Yes

Same direction across the trader's own accounts. Thor is included with TFeed.

Yes

PRO

  • Only allowed to copy trades from one PRO account to other PRO accounts of the exact same size.
  • Limited to a maximum of 5 PRO accounts for copy trading.
  • NOT allowed: copying between S2F Sim Pro and Instant Sim Funded, or between S2F and Elite plans.

Classic ELITE & Instant Sim

  • Only allowed to copy trades between accounts of the same type and same size
  • Limited to a maximum of 3 ELITE Sim accounts or Instant Sim accounts for copy trading.

ELITE DAILY

  • Copy trade up to 5 accounts.

IGNITE

  • Copy trading allowed on up to 10 IGNITE accounts of the same size
  • Not allowed: between different plan types (IGNITE to Instant or Elite), or between different IGNITE sizes

Copy Trading Between Firms:

  • It's allowed but all trade decisions must originate from activity on their platform.
News Trading
Yes

Including Tier 1 releases, at every stage.

Yes

News trading allowed by default on all account types, with two exceptions:

Elite Daily (Funded)

  • No trades 2 minutes before or after high-impact news events

Elite ACCESS (Funded)

  • No trades 2 minutes before or after high-impact news events

Elite Challenge / Instant / S2F / IGNITE: no news restriction.

Inactivity Rule

Pre-funded: one trade every 7 calendar days, otherwise the account closes without a payout. Live: 30 days, not applied mechanically. Challenges: none, except Spark (90 days).

Yes

14 calendar days without a trade (entry and exit) results in hard breach. The 14-day window includes weekends and holidays. Applies to all account types.

Consistency Rule
Limited

Classic and Daily evaluations: best day up to 50% of total profit; exceeding it only delays passing. Spark funded: 30%. No rule on Classic and Daily funded, Spark evaluation or Merit.

Yes
  • INSTANT: To request a payout, no single trading day's profit can exceed 20% of your total accumulated profits
  • ELITE (funded phase): 25%
  • ELITE DAILY (evaluation only): 45% V1 / 40% V2 (accounts from 5/11/26)
  • ELITE ACCESS (funded): 40%
  • IGNITE: 15%
  • PRO: You need an ESS score of 20% to request a payout. To calculate ESS Score: (Best Day Profit + Worst Day Loss [as a positive number]) ÷ Total Profit × 100%
  • X-ULTRA: 50% during evaluation (best day / total profit); none when funded.
Hold Weekend
No
No

All trades must be closed by 4:10 PM EST. The system force-liquidates any open positions at that time. No overnight or weekend holding allowed. Weekend trading is prohibited.

Trading hours: 6:00 PM EST (Sunday) to 4:10 PM EST (Friday), with a daily break from 5:00 PM to 6:00 PM EST.

Prohibited Strategies

Hedging between accounts, account rolling, martingale or loss recovery across accounts (also at other firms) and HFT or bots. On funded accounts: flipping and one-tick trading on bonds. Stop trading a contract within 2% of its CME daily price limit.

  • Exploiting System, Pricing, or Latency Errors
  • Use of Insider or Non-Public Information
  • Front-Running
  • Hedging Between Accounts
  • Unauthorized Account Access
  • Minimum Trade Duration (10-Second Rule)
  • Trading That Risks Broker Relationships
  • Trading That May Create Regulatory Concerns
  • Externally Marked Challenge-Passing Strategies
  • Rolling, Churning, or Gambling Accounts
Overnight positions
No

Positions must be closed before the session ends, at every stage including Live. Breach: funded account denied, or payout denied and account closed.

No
Requires Stop Loss
No data
No
Maximum Risk Limit
No data
No
Free newsletter

Pick your firms. Get what matters.

  • Exclusive promotions, updated daily
  • Funded trading industry news
  • Full control: you choose which firms to follow

FreeNo spamOne-click unsubscribe

Community

Join the community

Join us on our mission to become the most influential family in funded trading.

  • trade-ideasTrading ideas from the community
  • giveawaysGiveaways from prop firms
  • respect-leaderboardTop 10 by Respect earned
  • wins-and-lossesFundings, payouts and blown accounts
Join the Discord