Scalping and High-Frequency Trading
Both firms allow scalping, but the technical environment and specific restrictions differ significantly.
- Rules and Limitations: AquaFunded allows scalping and, unlike many competitors, permits stacking and martingale strategies. However, the "Wave Stop" rule is a major risk for scalpers: if floating losses hit 2% of the balance, all positions are closed automatically. CTI allows scalping but explicitly prohibits stacking, grid trading, and martingale (except in the 1-Step challenge).
- Platforms: Scalpers at AquaFunded can choose between MetaTrader 5, MatchTrader, TradeLocker, and cTrader, providing more options for execution speed. CTI is limited to MetaTrader 5 and MatchTrader.
- Costs: Both firms charge a $5 per lot commission on Forex. For indices, AquaFunded is commission-free, while CTI charges $0.5 per lot.
- Risk: AquaFunded’s trailing drawdown (on Standard/Pro accounts) based on the higher of equity or balance makes scalping dangerous during high volatility. CTI uses static drawdown for its 2-Step and Instant programs, which is generally safer for this style.
Automated Trading with EAs
The approach to automation varies between the "anything goes" model of AquaFunded and the "proprietary" model of CTI.
- Rules and Limitations: AquaFunded allows EAs with very few restrictions, making it suitable for those using commercial or custom bots. CTI allows EAs but prohibits the use of 3rd-party EAs (bots sold to many users) in its 2-Step and Instant challenges; they are only allowed in the 1-Step challenge.
- Interaction with other rules: CTI requires a stop loss on every trade. If your EA doesn't set one, the system will close the trade after 1 minute (soft breach). AquaFunded does not require a stop loss, but its "Wave Stop" acts as a global emergency brake for the account.
- Prohibited Strategies: Both firms ban latency arbitrage, high-frequency trading (HFT), and exploiting price feeds.
News Trading
If you trade during high-impact events, the choice between these firms depends on whether you prefer profit caps or total freedom.
- Rules and Limitations: CTI allows news trading without specific documented restrictions. AquaFunded has a strict policy for funded accounts: profits generated 5 minutes before or after "red folder" news or FOMC are capped at 0.5% of the starting balance. Any profit above that cap is removed.
- Risk: The volatility during news can easily trigger AquaFunded's 2% Wave Stop or CTI’s mandatory stop-loss soft breach if the execution slips.
- Payout Influence: Since AquaFunded caps news profits, this style is less effective for "big hit" traders and better suited for those who simply want to keep positions open during news without being the main source of their gains.
Swing Trading and Weekend Holding
Both firms are relatively friendly to long-term traders, but the cost of carrying positions is the deciding factor.
- Weekend Holding: Both AquaFunded and CTI allow holding positions over the weekend across all their main programs.
- Swap Costs: AquaFunded offers swap-free accounts, allowing traders to hold positions indefinitely without overnight costs. CTI also offers swap-free options, though they emphasize institutional-grade conditions for their Gold VIP tier.
- Trading Days: Neither firm imposes a maximum trading day limit, which is ideal for swing traders waiting for long-term setups.
Copy Trading and Hedging
This is where the two firms diverge most sharply, with AquaFunded being much more permissive.
- Copy Trading: AquaFunded allows copy trading between its own accounts, from external accounts, and even from evaluation to funded accounts. CTI strictly prohibits all forms of copy trading.
- Hedging: AquaFunded allows hedging. CTI prohibits hedging and group hedging.
- Alternatives: If you rely on these styles, CTI is not a viable option. At CTI, these are considered prohibited strategies that can lead to account termination.
If you trade like this
- If you are a Scalper or EA user who uses Martingale or Stacking: AquaFunded is the only choice, as CTI prohibits these specific mathematical strategies.
- If you are a Disciplined Manual Trader who wants 100% of profits: City Traders Imperium is better, provided you always use a stop loss and don't mind the slower scaling to reach the Silver/Gold VIP tiers.
- If you use Copy Trading or Hedging: AquaFunded is your only option here, as CTI bans both practices.
- If you trade News aggressively: City Traders Imperium is superior because it does not impose the 0.5% profit cap that AquaFunded applies to news events.
Frequently asked questions
Which firm is cheaper to start, AquaFunded or City Traders Imperium?
City Traders Imperium is slightly more accessible for very small budgets, offering a $2,500 1-Step challenge for $29 and a 2-Step version for $39. AquaFunded’s cheapest standard option is the $5,000 2-Step Elite for $33. However, for a $100,000 account, AquaFunded is generally cheaper, with its 2-Step Pro priced at $429 compared to CTI’s $549 for the same size.
Which firm allows EAs with fewer restrictions, AquaFunded or City Traders Imperium?
AquaFunded is significantly less restrictive, as it allows 3rd-party EAs and does not require a stop loss. City Traders Imperium only allows 3rd-party EAs in its 1-Step challenge and requires a stop loss to be placed within 60 seconds on every trade, which can be a limitation for some automated systems.
Which firm pays out faster, AquaFunded or City Traders Imperium?
AquaFunded generally offers a faster initial payout cycle, with the first withdrawal available 14 days after the first trade (or even 7 days with a paid add-on). City Traders Imperium requires 7 profitable trading days (minimum 0.5% profit each) and a 2% net profit for the first payout, and subsequent payouts for their 1-Step and 2-Step programs are typically monthly.
Can I use copy trading in AquaFunded or City Traders Imperium?
You can use copy trading in AquaFunded, including copying from external accounts or between AquaFunded accounts. In contrast, City Traders Imperium strictly prohibits all forms of copy trading, and violating this rule is considered a prohibited strategy that can lead to the loss of the account.



















