/
Login
Breaking
All news
Comparison · Futures

Long-term growth and capital scaling: Blue Guardian Futures vs. Phidias Propfirm

Choosing between Blue Guardian Futures and Phidias Propfirm is a choice between immediate high profit shares and a professional path toward massive capital allocation. While Blue Guardian focuses on speed and a flat 90% split, Phidias offers a structured environment that can lead to a $600,000 allocation and 100% profit shares for consistent traders.

Updated on

Day one

The point of entry defines your initial costs and the speed at which you can start earning.

  • Entry Price and Evaluation:
    • Blue Guardian Futures: Offers the "Direct" plan, which bypasses evaluation entirely (instant funding) starting at $307 for a $25k account. For those preferring evaluations, the "Standard" plan can be passed in just one day, while the "Reserve" and "Express" plans have no minimum trading days.
    • Phidias Propfirm: Provides a highly flexible entry. The "Express to Live" (E2L) plan features a 0-day evaluation, meaning you can move to a CASH account immediately after hitting the target. Prices vary between monthly subscriptions (e.g., $164 for a $50k Fundamental) and one-time payments.
  • Platforms and Technology:
    • Blue Guardian Futures: Limited to Tradovate, ProjectX, Volsys, and DeepCharts.
    • Phidias Propfirm: Offers a professional suite including NinjaTrader, TradingView, Rithmic, Quantower, and Bookmap. This is a significant advantage for traders who rely on specific order-flow tools.
  • Initial Restrictions:
    • Blue Guardian prohibits all forms of EAs and automated trading.
    • Phidias allows semi-automated software as long as the trader manually adjusts and monitors every trade.

The first months

Once funded, the focus shifts to risk management and the first withdrawal cycles.

  • Risk Guardrails:
    • Blue Guardian Futures: Uses a trailing End-of-Day (EOD) drawdown. A unique "Daily Loss Limit" exists as a soft breach; if hit, the account is only disabled for the day, not failed. They also enforce a 5:1 maximum risk-to-reward ratio.
    • Phidias Propfirm: E2L accounts use a static drawdown (it never moves up), which is a massive advantage for longevity. Fundamental and Premium plans use EOD trailing drawdown.
  • Payout Mechanics:
    • Blue Guardian Futures: Offers a 90% profit split across all plans. Payouts can be requested every 3 days (Standard) or daily (Express). They provide a 24-business-hour guarantee; if they miss it, you get an extra 10% profit share.
    • Phidias Propfirm: The split starts at 80% for E2L and Fundamental. The Premium plan starts at 75% but scales up to 100% by the fifth payout. Payout frequency ranges from daily (E2L Live) to every 10 days (Fundamental).
  • Consistency Rules:
    • Blue Guardian: Usually a 40% rule (no single day can exceed 40% of total profit).
    • Phidias: 30% consistency rule on CASH accounts, plus minimum profitable day requirements ($150–$250 depending on size).

The first year

For the trader who survives the first quarter, scaling and account accumulation become the priority.

  • Scaling Programs:
    • Blue Guardian Futures: Scaling is only available for Reserve and Express plans. It is balance-based: as your EOD balance grows, your contract limits increase. For example, a $100k account starts with 3 minis and can grow to 8 minis after gaining $3,000 in profit.
    • Phidias Propfirm: Offers a professional tier system. LIVE accounts can advance to "ELITE" after 60 days and a $125k balance, or "MASTER" after 120 days and a $250k balance. This transition is subject to risk team review but represents a more institutional path.
  • Account Management:
    • Blue Guardian: Maximum allocation is capped at $150,000.
    • Phidias: Allows a much higher ceiling with up to 5 simultaneous accounts per category, reaching a total maximum allocation of $600,000.
  • Operational Freedom:
    • Phidias "Premium" plans allow for overnight and weekend holding, which is essential for swing traders over a one-year horizon. Blue Guardian requires all positions to close daily.

The ceiling

The "ceiling" represents the ultimate potential of each firm.

  • Blue Guardian Futures: The limit is $150,000. While the 90% split is generous, the capital growth is restricted compared to competitors. The scaling is designed to increase contract sizes rather than providing millions in managed capital.
  • Phidias Propfirm: The ceiling is $600,000 in allocation. Furthermore, the Premium plan's 100% profit share (from the 5th payout onwards) is the highest possible ceiling in the industry. The transition from CASH to LIVE accounts is the ultimate goal, where withdrawal limits are removed.

Room to grow

Blue Guardian Futures is built for the "sprint." It is ideal for traders who want to skip evaluations (Direct plan), keep 90% of their gains from day one, and receive payouts almost instantly with a 24-hour guarantee. It is a high-speed, high-reward environment with strict rules against automation and weekend holding.

Phidias Propfirm is built for the "marathon." It offers a significantly higher capital ceiling ($600k vs $150k), a path to 100% profit sharing, and professional-grade platforms like NinjaTrader and TradingView. With the ability to hold positions over the weekend (Premium) and a static drawdown (E2L), it provides the necessary tools for a trader to evolve into a professional fund manager.

Frequently asked questions

Which firm is cheaper to start with, Blue Guardian Futures or Phidias Propfirm?

Phidias Propfirm is generally more affordable for a standard evaluation, offering $50,000 Fundamental accounts for a $164 monthly fee or $50,000 E2L accounts for $278 (Evaluation + Activation). Blue Guardian Futures is more expensive at the entry point if you choose the "Direct" (no evaluation) path, which costs $494 for a $50,000 account, although their $50,000 "Reserve" evaluation is very competitive at $100.

Who offers better payout conditions, Blue Guardian Futures or Phidias Propfirm?

Blue Guardian Futures offers a superior starting profit split of 90% and a 24-business-hour processing guarantee with a 10% penalty if they delay. Phidias Propfirm starts lower at 75% or 80%, but it is the only one of the two that allows you to eventually reach a 100% profit share on the Premium plan after five successful payout cycles.

Can I use automated trading or EAs on Blue Guardian Futures or Phidias Propfirm?

Blue Guardian Futures strictly prohibits all forms of EAs, bots, and fully automated trading mechanisms. Phidias Propfirm also prohibits fully automated HFT and robots, but they are more flexible by allowing semi-automated software, provided the trader is actively monitoring and manually adjusting the entries and exits.

Which firm allows for a higher maximum capital allocation, Blue Guardian Futures or Phidias Propfirm?

Phidias Propfirm offers a significantly higher ceiling, allowing traders to manage up to $600,000 across multiple accounts. Blue Guardian Futures has a much lower maximum allocation limit, capped at $150,000 total across all plans, making Phidias the better choice for traders looking to manage large amounts of capital.

Field by field

Blue Guardian Futures and Phidias Propfirm, side by side

Rules, plans, platforms, leverage, commissions and payouts of both, with the option to see only what differs.

Head to head

52 differences

80%off · Exclusive
Headquarters

Algaroud Center, 2nd Floor, Office 101-05, Dubai, UAE

Suite 4.3.02, Block 4, Eurotowers, Gibraltar, GX11 1AA

CEO

Sean Bainton

No data
Country

United Arab Emirates

Gibraltar

Foundation

2021

2023

Banned Countries
Afghanistan, Albania, Algeria, Angola, Bahamas, Barbados, Belarus, Bosnia & Herzegovina, Botswana, Bulgaria, Burma (Myanmar), Burundi, Burkina Faso, Cambodia, Cameroon, Central African Republic, China, Côte d'Ivoire, Crimea, Croatia, Cuba, Democratic Republic of Congo, Ecuador, Ethiopia, Ghana, Haiti, Hong Kong, Iceland, Indonesia, Iran, Iraq, Jamaica, Kenya, Kosovo, Laos, Lebanon, Liberia, Libya, Macedonia, Mali, Mauritius, Mongolia, Montenegro, Mozambique, Namibia, Nicaragua, Nigeria, North Korea, Pakistan, Panama, Papua New Guinea, Philippines, Qatar, Romania, Russia, Senegal, Serbia, Slovenia, Somalia, South Africa, South Sudan, Sri Lanka, Sudan, Syria, Tanzania, Trinidad and Tobago, Tunisia, Turkey, Uganda, Ukraine, Venezuela, Vietnam, Yemen
Afghanistan, Albania, Algeria, Angola, Belarus, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Botswana, Bulgaria, Burkina Faso, Burundi, Central African Republic, Croatia, Cuba, Dem. Rep. Congo, Ecuador, Ethiopia, Guyana, Haiti, Indonesia, Iran, Iraq, Jamaica, Kenya, Kosovo, Laos, Lebanon, Libya, Macedonia, Mali, Malta, Mauritius, Montenegro, Mozambique, Myanmar (Burma), Namibia, Nicaragua, Nigeria, North Korea (DPRK), Pakistan, Papua New Guinea, Philippines, Romania, Russia, Senegal, Serbia, Slovenia, Somalia, South Africa, South Sudan, Sri Lanka, Sudan/Darfur, Syria, Tanzania, Trinidad and Tobago, Tunisia, Crimea (Ukraine), Venezuela, Yemen, Zimbabwe
Assets
No data
Indices, Interest Rates, Currencies, Cryptocurrencies, Agriculture, Energies, Metals
Refund
No
No data
Payout Fee

2% processing fee on all withdrawals (Riseworks).

No data
Platforms
Tradovate, ProjectX, Volsys, DeepCharts
RTrader Pro, Rithmic, Tradovate, NinjaTrader, Tradingview, DeepCharts, Quantower, MotiveWave, ATAS, Sierra Chart, Bookmap, Jigsaw
Demo Account
Unknown
No data
Payout Methods
Transfer, Crypto
Rise, Transfer, Crypto
Live Account
Yes

After completing the evaluation and trading consistently on a Simulated Funded Account, the Risk Management team may invite traders to Live. There is no fixed timeline; each trader is evaluated individually. From 28/09/2026, all eligible funded accounts merge into one Live Account at transition. Their starting Live drawdowns add together: five $50K accounts provide $10,000 of combined drawdown. The $15,000 cap applies to new purchases after 28/09/2026. Contract limits scale with the combined drawdown, up to 10 minis / 100 micros. At each live profit milestone of 0.5x, 1x and 1.5x the starting drawdown, 25% of that drawdown is deposited into the Live balance as a bonus. The bonus becomes withdrawable after five winning days with the account in profit. Instead of trading Live, the trader may choose a one-time Live Buyout of 50% of the combined starting drawdown at transition. It is available once per trader, with a 28-day cooldown afterward. Live accounts use end-of-day drawdown with no daily loss limit. CME professional data, trade commissions and platform fees are deducted from the balance. Contract limits may increase with consistent performance.

Yes

Express to Live converts the CASH account to LIVE after reaching its CASH target and requesting the first payout through “Switch to Live”. Phidias states that the full path from signup to first payout and LIVE conversion can be completed in 48 hours on every E2L size. Fundamental and Premium may transition to LIVE after 5 payouts or $100,000 in cumulative profits, subject to the risk team’s discretion.

Payment Methods
Card, Crypto, ApplePay, GooglePay
Card
Payout Frequency
  • Standard: every 3 days, from 3 days after the first trade
  • Reserve: instant payout once eligible (5 winning days)
  • Express: daily payouts
  • Direct: instant payout from day one

Withdrawal eligibility is confirmed by the end-of-day (EOD) dashboard update. Once the withdrawal button is enabled, a request can be submitted at any time without waiting for the next EOD update.

Fundamental: every 10 qualifying trading days. Premium: every 5 qualifying days. LIVE from Express to Live: daily.

Payout Guarantee

Payouts processed within 24 business hours. If Blue Guardian misses that window through a delay on their end, you receive an extra 10% profit share on that payout. Does not apply on weekends or bank holidays, nor to delays from compliance or risk reviews, Rise onboarding or a pending trader response.

Phidias states that 90% of payouts are processed in under 30 minutes and all payouts within 24 hours.

Minimum Withdrawal

$500 across all account types.

$500.

Brokers
No data
Dorman Trading
Maximum Withdrawal
No data

Fundamental and Premium: up to $2,000 per cycle on 50K, $2,500 on 100K, and $2,750 on 150K. LIVE accounts originating from Express to Live have no maximum daily limit.

Other Payout Requirements
No data

Fundamental and Premium apply a 30% consistency rule on CASH accounts. A qualifying day must generate at least $150 on 50K, $200 on 100K, or $250 on 150K. Express to Live uses a separate bonus and automatic LIVE conversion system.

Account Reset
Yes

Evaluation accounts can be reset at 30% off the original price. After failing the evaluation, the trader has 7 days to decide whether to reset. Funded accounts cannot be reset.

Limited

Fundamental and Premium allow unlimited evaluation resets. A failed subscription also resets with the next 30-day renewal. Express to Live does not allow resets. Premium CASH permits one funded-account reset.

Add-ons
Yes

Reserve challenges are configurable at checkout. Traders can choose a Daily Loss Limit or no Daily Loss Limit, combined with a 40% consistency rule (3-day pass) or a 50% consistency rule (2-day pass). The price varies depending on the selected combination.

Express challenges offer an optional 50% evaluation consistency add-on instead of the standard 40% rule, allowing traders to qualify after as few as 2 green days.

Yes

Market-depth data and additional exchanges can be purchased from the member area.

Instant
Yes
No
One Step
Yes
Yes
Account scaling
Yes

Scaling applies to funded Reserve and Express accounts only. Standard and Direct keep flat contract limits from start to finish.

On Reserve and Express you get full contract size during the evaluation, and funded limits start lower and grow with the account balance. Updated at end of day (EOD) on the closing balance; if the EOD balance drops below a trigger, the tier can go back down.

Starting funded limits

  • $25,000: 1 mini / 10 micros
  • $50,000: 2 minis / 20 micros
  • $100,000: 3 minis / 30 micros
  • $150,000: 3 minis / 30 micros

Scaling triggers ($25K / $50K / $100K / $150K)

  • +$1,500: 2/20 · 3/30 · 4/40 · 4/40
  • +$2,000: — · 4/40 · 5/50 · 5/50
  • +$3,000: — · — · 8/80 · 8/80
  • +$4,500: — · — · — · 12/120

Flat limits (Standard and Direct)

  • $25,000: 1 mini / 10 micros
  • $50,000: 4 minis / 40 micros
  • $100,000: 8 minis / 80 micros
  • $150,000: 12 minis / 120 micros

1 mini = 10 micros; contracts can be mixed within the limit.

Limited

LIVE accounts may advance to ELITE after 60 days and a $125,000 balance, or MASTER after 120 days and $250,000. Transition remains subject to risk review.

Two Steps
No
No data
Max Drawdown

Trailing end-of-day (EOD) on all plans. Values per plan and size:

  • Standard $25K / $50K / $100K / $150K: $1,500 / $2,000 / $3,500 / $5,000
  • Reserve $25K / $50K / $100K / $150K: $1,000 / $2,000 / $3,000 / $4,500
  • Express $25K / $50K / $100K / $150K: $1,000 / $2,000 / $2,500 / $3,500
  • Direct $25K / $50K / $100K / $150K: $1,500 / $2,000 / $3,500 / $4,500

Once the trailing drawdown reaches the starting balance, it locks and stops trailing.

On Direct the drawdown becomes static after the account exceeds the initial trail balance or after the first payout request. After any approved payout the drawdown floor locks at starting balance + $100 on every plan.

Express to Live uses a static drawdown that never moves. Fundamental and Premium use trailing drawdown calculated at the end of the day; the limit remains fixed during the session.

Profit Split

90% on all funded accounts and plans.

A payout delayed beyond the 24-business-hour guarantee adds an extra 10% profit share on that payout.

Express to Live and Fundamental: 80%. Premium: 75% on the first payout, 80% on the second, 85% on the third, 90% on the fourth, and 100% from the fifth onward.

Daily Drawdown

Soft breach on every plan: open trades are closed automatically and the account is disabled for the rest of the day, then reinstated the next trading day.

  • Standard $25K: none. $50K / $100K / $150K: $1,000 / $2,000 / $3,000
  • Reserve: configurable at checkout. Traders can choose no daily loss limit or a soft DLL of $600 / $1,200 / $1,700 / $3,000 on $25K / $50K / $100K / $150K. The price varies depending on the selected option
  • Express challenge $25K: none. $50K / $100K / $150K: $1,000 / $1,250 / $1,750
  • Express funded $25K / $50K / $100K / $150K: $500 / $1,000 / $1,250 / $1,750
  • Direct $25K / $50K / $100K / $150K: $1,000 / $1,250 / $2,500 / $3,000

There is no daily loss limit on Express to Live, Fundamental, or Premium.

Three Steps
No
No data
Max Allocation
150,000
600,000
Mandatory buffer
Limited

Standard — Funded Buffer

  • $25,000 → $1,600
  • $50,000 → $2,100
  • $100,000 → $3,600
  • $150,000 → $5,100

Payouts are only available from profits earned above the buffer, and the buffer must stay intact when submitting a request.

Express

  • $25,000 → $1,100
  • $50,000 → $2,100
  • $100,000 → $3,600
  • $150,000 → $5,100

Payouts are only available from profits earned above the buffer.

Reserve

  • No buffer to reach before a payout, but after any withdrawal the drawdown floor locks at starting balance + $100.

Direct

  • No profit buffer requirement.
No

A minimum threshold applies when requesting a payout, but withdrawals may reduce the balance to $50,100, $100,100, or $150,100. Phidias does not treat this as a locked buffer.

Minimum Trading Days
  • No minimum trading days on evaluation. Standard can be passed in as little as one trading day
  • Express with the optional 50% consistency add-on can qualify after 2 green days
  • Funded: one trade every 7 days to keep the account active

Evaluation: 0 days on Express to Live, 3 on Fundamental, and 1 on Premium. CASH: 0 days for the Express to Live bonus, 10 qualifying days between payouts on Fundamental, and 5 on Premium.

Funded Phase Pricing Model

No activation

No data
Minimum Profitable Days
  • Standard: no minimum. First payout 3 days after the first trade
  • Reserve: 5 winning days before each payout, with a minimum of $100 / $150 / $200 / $250 profit per day on $25K / $50K / $100K / $150K. Winning days reset after every payout
  • Express: no minimum
  • Direct: no minimum

On Fundamental and Premium CASH accounts, a qualifying day must close with at least $150 on 50K, $200 on 100K, or $250 on 150K.

Position size scaling
No
Limited

On LIVE accounts, traders may request a contract-limit increase in writing. The risk team may approve, reject, or adjust the limit.

Evaluation Phase Pricing Model

One-time fee

No data
Free Trial
No data
No
Maximum Accounts
No data

Unlimited evaluation accounts. A trader may operate a LIVE account while pursuing a new evaluation. Simultaneous maximum: 5 Fundamental CASH, 5 Premium CASH, and 5 Express to Live CASH/LIVE accounts. The 10K Drawdown Summer Edition allows unlimited simultaneous entries, with only the trader’s best account counting on the leaderboard. Fundamental and Premium 150K accounts count as two slots in their category.

Points Reward Program
No data

Phidias Wallet centralizes account subscriptions, bank or cryptocurrency withdrawals, purchases, activations, and LIVE-account funding directly from earnings. Phidias Points are an internal unit that cannot be transferred outside the ecosystem.

Expert Advisor (EA)
No
No

Robots, fully automated algorithms, and HFT are prohibited. Semi-automated software is allowed when the trader actively monitors and manually adjusts every trade.

VPN
Yes
No
Hedging
Yes
No

Hedging is prohibited on the same underlying within one account (including ES vs MES), between CASH accounts, and through coordinated opposite trades between traders; violations can close all involved accounts and lead to a ban. Multiple assets may be traded simultaneously, but the contract cap applies across all symbols; bypassing it can close the account without refund.

Requires Stop Loss
No
No
Scalping
Yes

Microscalping (trades held seconds with minimal profit margins) is prohibited. Automated scalping systems that exceed 200 trades per day are not allowed. Exploiting tight brackets or the simulated market's absence of slippage is forbidden.

Yes
Stacking / Layering (DCA)
Yes
Yes

DCA is allowed to smooth entry points, provided consistent risk management is maintained.

Martingale
Yes
No
Maximum Risk Limit
Yes

Max risk-to-reward ratio: 5:1. For every $100 of profit target, your initial stop loss cannot exceed $500. Mental stops are accepted but excessive risk-taking can lead to warnings or payout disqualification. Adjusting stops to add risk goes against policy; only move stops forward to trail and protect profits.

Additional risk guardrails:

  • Trade within 2% of any CME price limit is prohibited.
  • Trading without clear risk management, excessive sizing, inconsistent contract sizes or "all-in" strategies may be considered gambling and lead to account review.
  • Holding a position into the daily 16:10 EST auto-close is fine; the auto-close itself doesn't breach the account.
Limited

Phidias requires consistent position sizing and risk management. Lottery-style trading, excessive margin usage, or non-replicable patterns may lead to reduced contracts or account closure.

Copy Trading
No
Yes

Allowed within the maximum account limits. Identical strategies exceeding the authorized allocation may result in account suspension.

News Trading
Yes

Allowed on both challenge and funded accounts, on every plan. Traders can open, manage and close positions during high-impact news. Blue Guardian warns that slippage and spread widening may occur.

Yes
Inactivity Rule

At least one trade every 7 days on funded accounts.

No data
Consistency Rule
Yes

A single trading day cannot equal or exceed:

  • Standard: 40%, on the funded account only
  • Reserve: configurable as 40% (3-day pass) or 50% (2-day pass), on the evaluation only
  • Express: 40% on the evaluation by default; an optional 50% evaluation consistency add-on allows qualification after as few as 2 green days
  • Direct: 20% on the first payout, 25% on the second, 30% from the third onwards

Calculation: Highest Net Profit Day / Total Account PnL. On evaluation accounts, passing is delayed until the ratio complies with the selected threshold. On funded accounts, payouts are blocked until the ratio drops below the applicable threshold. Violating the rule does NOT terminate the account.

Limited

There is no consistency rule during evaluation or on Express to Live. On Fundamental and Premium CASH accounts, no single day may represent more than 30% of total profit. It is calculated over at least 4 days.

Hold Weekend
No
Limited

Allowed only on Premium. Fundamental and Express to Live must close before the end of the session.

Prohibited Strategies
  • Automated scalping systems exceeding 200 trades per day.
  • AI, bots and fully automated trading mechanisms (all account types).
  • Hands-off, continuous day-and-night trading or complete automation.
  • Placing multiple limit orders at the same price to manipulate fills.
  • Strategies aimed at exploiting isolated fills in low-liquidity or gapped markets.
  • Using tight brackets or absence of slippage in the simulated market for favorable fills.
  • Trading during tier 1 economic data releases.
  • Coordinated trading across unconnected accounts (identical or opposing strategies).
  • Microscalping (trades held seconds with minimal margins).
  • Trading within 2% of a CME price limit.
  • Trading without a stop loss, relying on the trailing threshold to close trades.

Robots and fully automated trading; HFT; lottery-style or full-margin trades during high-volatility news; old or illiquid contracts; spreads between expirations; one-tick Treasury-bond arbitrage; exploitation of technical or market errors.

Overnight positions
No
Limited

Allowed only on Premium. Fundamental and Express to Live must close before the end of the session.

Free newsletter

Pick your firms. Get what matters.

  • Exclusive promotions, updated daily
  • Funded trading industry news
  • Full control: you choose which firms to follow

FreeNo spamOne-click unsubscribe

Community

Join the community

Join us on our mission to become the most influential family in funded trading.

  • trade-ideasTrading ideas from the community
  • giveawaysGiveaways from prop firms
  • respect-leaderboardTop 10 by Respect earned
  • wins-and-lossesFundings, payouts and blown accounts
Join the Discord