1. Program Variety and Evaluation Structures
Both firms provide a wide array of account types, but their approach to evaluation differs significantly in complexity and flexibility.
- Maven offers high diversity with 1, 2, and 3-Step evaluations, plus Instant and Mini accounts. The 3-Step model is particularly notable for having lower profit targets (3% per phase), catering to conservative traders.
- FundingPips focuses on 1 and 2-Step evaluations and a unique "Zero" model. While they lack a 3-step option, their "2 Step Pro" allows for passing in a single day, offering faster progression for high-frequency traders.
- Instant Funding Differences: Maven’s "Mini Account" is designed for extremely short-term goals (24h duration, one-time payout), whereas FundingPips Zero is a long-term model with a "Safety Cushion" where the first 3% of profit is non-withdrawable.
2. Payout Dynamics and Profit Sharing
The withdrawal process reveals the most significant differences in how these firms manage their capital and reward traders.
- Withdrawal Caps: Maven imposes a strict $10,000 cap per 30-day rolling cycle. Additionally, once a trader exceeds $5,000 in total payouts, they must pass a risk interview. Failure to attend or pass results in non-payment.
- Payout Frequency: FundingPips is superior in flexibility, offering On-Demand payouts for standard accounts. In contrast, Maven requires a 10-day wait period between payouts.
- Profit Split: Maven maintains a fixed 80% split. FundingPips uses a variable system ranging from 60% to 100%, depending on the payout frequency chosen and the scaling level achieved.
- Consistency Rules:
- Maven: No single trade or day can exceed 50% of the total profit (for payouts over $5,000).
- FundingPips: No single day can exceed 35% of total profit (for On-Demand accounts) or 15% (for Zero accounts).
3. Drawdown Logic and Risk Management
Understanding how these firms calculate losses is vital to avoiding accidental breaches.
- Daily Drawdown: Both firms utilize an EOD (End of Day) High-Watermark based on the highest balance or equity recorded at the close of the day. This is generally more trader-friendly than "Balance-based" daily limits but requires careful management of floating profits.
- Maximum Drawdown:
- Maven uses Static drawdown for 2 and 3-step evaluations but Trailing drawdown for 1-step and Instant accounts.
- FundingPips uses Static drawdown for 1 and 2-step evaluations, but the Zero account uses Trailing drawdown.
- The 1% Floating Rule (Maven): On Instant and Mini accounts at Maven, the gap between balance and equity must never exceed 1%. This effectively acts as a very tight "hidden" stop-loss on floating PnL.
4. Strategic Restrictions and News Trading
Both firms have strict rules regarding how and when you can trade, specifically targeting automation and high-impact events.
- Expert Advisors (EAs): Both firms officially prohibit fully autonomous EAs. Trading must be manual or use EAs only as assistive tools for manual execution.
- News Trading:
- Maven: Strict 2-minute window (before and after) where opening, closing, or hitting TP/SL is prohibited during high-impact news.
- FundingPips: No restrictions during evaluations. However, on funded accounts, profits from trades within a 5-minute window of news are voided unless the position was held for at least 5 hours prior.
- Scalping: Maven prohibits having more than 50% of trades open for less than 1 minute. FundingPips is more lenient toward scalping but has simultaneous lot limits (e.g., 40 lots max for $100k+ accounts).
5. Scaling and Growth Potential
FundingPips offers a more structured corporate-style progression compared to Maven's percentage-based increases.
- FundingPips Scaling: Features a 5-level system. At Level 4 ("Hot Seat"), the firm doubles the initial balance, provides a 100% profit split, and allows up to $2M in capital.
- Maven Scaling: Simpler but repeatable. Traders receive a 25% increase in capital for every 10% profit achieved over 4 months (with at least one payout per month). The cap is $1,000,000.
- Account Merging: Both allow merging master accounts, but FundingPips restricts this to the same evaluation model and excludes the Zero model.
6. Trading Costs and Platforms
- Platforms: Both offer MT5, MatchTrader, and cTrader, providing a modern suite of tools for the post-MT4 era.
- Commissions:
- Maven: ~$4/lot on Forex and ~$6/lot on Commodities.
- FundingPips: ~$5/lot on standard accounts, increasing to $7/lot on Zero accounts.
- Refunds: FundingPips is more accessible, offering a full refund with the first payout. Maven requires the trader to reach their third payout to receive a refund, significantly increasing the difficulty of recovering the initial fee.
7. Summary: Which Firm to Choose?
Choose Maven if:
- You prefer 3-step evaluations with lower individual profit targets.
- You want access to the "Buyback" feature, which allows you to bypass challenges and go straight to funding for a fee if you fail.
- You are a manual, swing, or day trader who doesn't mind a $10,000 monthly withdrawal cap and a risk interview.
Choose FundingPips if:
- You want On-Demand payouts and higher profit splits (up to 100%).
- You are a high-volume trader looking for a structured scaling plan up to $2M.
- You want your fee refund immediately upon the first successful payout.
- You trade from regions not banned by FundingPips (Note: FundingPips bans the USA and UAE, whereas Maven is more open but bans Russia and Belarus).



















