How you lose the account
Losing an account in these firms is not only about hitting a drawdown limit; it is about violating the operational boundaries set by their risk departments.
- Goat Funded Trader: You lose the account if you breach the daily or maximum drawdown, or if you remain inactive for 30 days. Additionally, using prohibited strategies like Martingale or Grid will result in a breach. A unique risk here is the "Goat Guard": if your open trades reach a 2% loss, the system may auto-close them. A second breach of this guard suspends the account.
- The5ers: Failure occurs by hitting drawdown limits or violating specific program rules. For instance, in the Bootcamp program, failing to set a Stop Loss or risking more than 2% per trade is a "grave violation." Inactivity of 30 days also terminates the account. They also ban HFT, arbitrage, and bracketing news.
Maximum drawdown
The maximum drawdown is the ultimate "hard stop" of your capital.
- Goat Funded Trader: Uses different models depending on the challenge. For 1-Step, 2-Step, and 3-Step evaluations, the drawdown is Static (it stays at a fixed price level based on the initial balance). However, in Instant Funding accounts, it is a Trailing drawdown, and in Instant Premium, it uses an EOD (End of Day) high-watermark.
- Numerical Example: In a $100,000 2-Step Standard account (10% Max Drawdown), your account is terminated if the equity ever touches $90,000. It doesn't matter if your balance grew to $110,000; the floor remains $90,000.
- The5ers: Most of their programs use a Balance-based drawdown. This is generally safer for the trader as it does not trail unrealized profits during the day.
- Numerical Example: In a $100,000 High Stakes account (10% Max Drawdown), the loss limit is fixed at $90,000. Like GFT's evaluation, it is static and does not move up as you gain profit.
Daily drawdown
This is the most common trap for traders, as it is often calculated on the higher of balance or equity at the start of the day.
- Goat Funded Trader: Calculated as an EOD high-watermark for most models. This means the limit for the next day is set based on the highest balance or equity recorded at the end of the previous day. For Instant HERO, it is strictly the daily starting balance at 5 PM EST.
- The5ers: Also uses the EOD high-watermark. Reaching this limit permanently terminates the account in the Summer Plan, whereas in Bootcamp, it triggers a "Daily Pause" (you can return the next day) only for funded accounts.
- Numerical Example: If you start the day with $100,000 in a The5ers High Stakes account (4% daily limit) and your equity reaches $105,000 but you don't close the trades, and then the market reverses, your daily limit for that same day is still $96,000. However, if you close at $105,000, the next day's limit starts from $105,000 ($100,800 limit).
Rules beyond drawdown
Risk management is also enforced through consistency and trade-level restrictions.
- Goat Funded Trader:
- Consistency Rule: In Instant accounts, a single day cannot represent more than 15% to 20% of total profits.
- News Trading: Profits from trades opened/closed 2 minutes around high-impact news are capped at 1% of the initial balance.
- Scalping: Funded accounts require a minimum holding time of 1 to 2 minutes.
- The5ers:
- Stop Loss: Mandatory in Bootcamp (must be placed within 3 minutes).
- Risk per trade: Maximum 2% risk per position in Bootcamp.
- Consistency Rule: Summer 1-Step and $100K/$200K Summer funded accounts have a 50% consistency rule for withdrawals.
- News Trading: High Stakes forbids opening/closing orders 2 minutes around news (results in profit deduction).
Risk that comes from the setup
The environment (platforms and execution) can cause "silent" risk through slippage or lack of tools.
- Goat Funded Trader: Offers a wide variety of platforms including MatchTrader, cTrader, TradeLocker, Volumetrica, and MetaTrader 5. This allows traders to choose the environment where they feel most secure. However, the 1-2 minute holding rule for scalpers on funded accounts is a significant execution risk; a fast trade that hits TP in 45 seconds will not count towards your payout.
- The5ers: Focuses on MetaTrader 5, cTrader, and TradingView. TradingView integration is a major advantage for risk visualization. Their execution is tied to a Liquidity Provider model. The prohibition of "News Bracketing" (placing buy/sell stops before news) is a restriction that prevents certain high-risk/high-reward volatility strategies.
What is at stake and what you recover
The cost of the challenge is the immediate risk, while the payout terms define how quickly you "de-risk" your investment.
- Goat Funded Trader: A $100,000 2-Step Goat account costs $478. You only recover this fee (refund) after your 4th payout. Payouts are biweekly, but can be "On Demand" with a paid add-on. There is a payout guarantee: if it takes more than 2 business days, you get an extra $500.
- The5ers: A $100,000 High Stakes account costs $455. The refund is much faster: Full refund after passing the evaluation. Payouts are available every 14 days once a minimum profit ($150-$500 depending on size) is reached. They also offer "Monthly Fixed Payouts" (up to $10,000) for high-level High Stakes traders who scale up.
Frequently asked questions
Which firm has a lower entry cost for a $100,000 account, Goat Funded Trader or The5ers?
The5ers is cheaper for this specific size. A $100,000 High Stakes account at The5ers costs $455, whereas the cheapest $100,000 2-step evaluation at Goat Funded Trader (the 2-Step Goat) costs $478. If you choose the 2-Step Standard at GFT, the price rises to $628.
Is the maximum drawdown more restrictive at Goat Funded Trader or The5ers?
It depends on the program, but The5ers is generally less restrictive because it uses a Balance-based (Static) drawdown in its main programs. Goat Funded Trader uses a Static drawdown for evaluations, but applies a Trailing drawdown for its Instant Funding accounts, which is more difficult to manage as the "floor" rises with your profits.
Which firm allows news trading with fewer penalties, Goat Funded Trader or The5ers?
The5ers is more flexible in its Hyper-Growth, ProGrowth, and Bootcamp programs, where news trading is fully allowed (except bracketing). In contrast, Goat Funded Trader caps profits at 1% of the initial balance for any trade affected by news, and The5ers' High Stakes program only deducts profits if you trade 2 minutes around the event.
Does Goat Funded Trader or The5ers require a mandatory Stop Loss?
The5ers has a much stricter requirement for its Bootcamp program, where a Stop Loss is mandatory and must be placed within 3 minutes of opening a trade, with a 2% maximum risk limit. Goat Funded Trader does not have a mandatory Stop Loss rule for its accounts, although it uses the "Goat Guard" system to monitor and potentially close high-loss positions.



















