Who is behind each firm
Midgard Trading is a United States-based entity, specifically Midgard Trading LLC, operating out of St. Petersburg, Florida. Their structure is built around a close integration with the regulated brokerage world, as they open live accounts through EdgeClear and the clearing firm Dorman. On the other hand, The5ers Futures is part of an established ecosystem led by CEO Saul Lokier, with headquarters in Ra’anana, Israel. While Midgard emphasizes its legal standing in the US and its path to real capital execution, The5ers operates as a proprietary trading platform where activity is conducted in a simulated environment, relying on its internal risk management and established reputation in the funding industry.
How long they have been around
The5ers is one of the veterans in the prop trading space, having been founded in 2016. This long-term presence is reflected in their massive public footprint, boasting approximately 20,000 Trustpilot reviews, which suggests a high volume of user interaction over nearly a decade. Midgard Trading represents a different profile in terms of documented history; while its legal entity is clearly defined in Florida, it does not currently show a significant volume of public reviews or a specific foundation date in the provided data. This makes The5ers the more "seasoned" option in terms of public exposure, while Midgard positions itself as a specialized futures firm with a focus on institutional-grade infrastructure.
What they promise and what backs it
The promises made by these firms are backed by very different operational philosophies. The5ers offers a scaling plan that can reach $500,000 and a consistency-based evaluation, backed by years of solvency and a large community. Their rules are relatively flexible, allowing Martingale and news trading, which suggests confidence in their simulated risk models. Midgard Trading, conversely, promises a transition to a real live account with actual capital after completing their "Ascension" cycles. This promise is backed by their relationship with EdgeClear and Dorman, though it comes with stricter risk rules, such as a prohibition on Martingale and specific restrictions on "microscalping" (trades under 12 seconds). Midgard’s pricing is generally higher—for example, a 50K "Light Armor" account costs $127 compared to The5ers' $100 "Day Trade" account—reflecting perhaps the costs of providing a path to real market execution rather than a pure simulation.
How they handle your money
Regarding payouts, both firms offer an 80% profit split, but the mechanics differ. The5ers allows withdrawals every 14 days, provided the trader has reached at least a 4% profit, and they charge a 3.5% fee for most methods (Rise, Crypto, Bank Transfer). Midgard Trading utilizes Rise and Dots for payments, with varying frequencies depending on the account type: the "Raid" accounts allow payouts once per CME session, while "Conquest" requires 5 days of minimum profit. Midgard does not list a specific withdrawal fee, but they do require a mandatory buffer in their Raid accounts, whereas The5ers does not. In terms of platforms, Midgard provides a wide array of industry standards like Rithmic, TradingView, and Sierra Chart, while The5ers focuses its futures operation on the BlackArrow platform.
Operational maturity
The operational maturity of The5ers is evident in its diverse payment methods (including Crypto) and its refined scaling rules, honed over years since 2016. They handle a high volume of traders and have a CEO who is a public figure in the industry. Midgard Trading shows its maturity through its regulatory alignment in the US and the complexity of its account tiers (Raid, Conquest, Ascension, Live). While Midgard lacks the sheer volume of public testimonials found with The5ers, its integration with clearing firms like Dorman indicates a high level of technical and legal sophistication that appeals to traders looking for a professional futures environment rather than a gamified experience.
What the record does and does not tell you
This comparison highlights the contrast between an established, high-volume firm (The5ers) and a specialized, US-based firm focused on real capital transition (Midgard). However, a high number of reviews does not guarantee individual success, nor does a US address guarantee a specific level of service. The data shows that The5ers offers more flexibility in trading styles and lower entry costs, while Midgard offers a more traditional brokerage-style environment with more platform choices. Traders must weigh the longevity and flexibility of The5ers against the institutional-grade path offered by Midgard.
Frequently asked questions
Which firm is more affordable for a $50,000 account, Midgard Trading or The5ers Futures?
The5ers Futures is the more affordable option for this account size. Their "Day Trade" 50K account has a one-time fee of $100, and their "Swing" version costs $120. In contrast, Midgard Trading charges $127 for its 50K "Light Armor" account and $170 for the "Plated" version. While Midgard's fees are higher, they do not charge a monthly subscription, similar to The5ers' one-time payment model.
Does Midgard Trading or The5ers Futures offer a more lenient drawdown rule?
The5ers Futures offers a more lenient drawdown structure by using an End-of-Day (EOD) trailing drawdown of 4%, which is calculated based on the highest balance or equity at midnight. Midgard Trading uses an intraday trailing drawdown that follows the highest equity in real-time, including unrealized profits. This means Midgard’s drawdown is more sensitive to price fluctuations during the trading session, making it more restrictive for the trader.
Which firm provides more platform options for futures trading, Midgard Trading or The5ers Futures?
Midgard Trading provides a significantly wider range of platforms, including Rithmic, TradingView, Sierra Chart, Bookmap, and MotiveWave, among others. This allows traders to use their preferred professional tools. The5ers Futures, however, is much more limited in this regard, as they currently only offer the BlackArrow platform for their futures programs.
Between Midgard Trading and The5ers Futures, which one is better for news trading or Martingale strategies?
The5ers Futures is better suited for these styles, as they explicitly allow news trading and Martingale strategies within their rules. Midgard Trading is much more restrictive: they prohibit Martingale and "averaging down," and they require traders to be flat (no open positions) during major news events like NFP, CPI, and FOMC once the account is funded.




















