Entry price
The cost of starting depends heavily on the chosen path. Blue Guardian Futures offers a much lower barrier to entry for standard evaluations.
- $50,000 account: Blue Guardian Reserve costs $100, while BrightFunded Plus costs $165.
- $100,000 account: Blue Guardian Reserve costs $148, while BrightFunded Plus costs $280.
- Instant access: Blue Guardian allows you to skip the evaluation with "Direct" accounts starting at $307 for $25k up to $824 for $150k. BrightFunded does not offer instant funding.
- Add-ons: BrightFunded prices can escalate quickly; adding a 100% profit split increases the base price by 20%, and doubling the payout cap adds 40%.
What you pay while trading
Operating costs differ in how they are billed. BrightFunded is transparent about commissions, while Blue Guardian defers certain costs to the professional phase.
- Commissions: BrightFunded charges $2.88 per side for main indices (ES/NQ). Blue Guardian mentions that commissions and platform fees are deducted from the balance once the trader moves to a Live account.
- Execution costs: BrightFunded imposes a "time cost" on scalpers; 50% of your winning profit must come from trades held longer than 15 seconds. If you trade faster, your profits don't count toward your target, forcing you to trade more and pay more in commissions.
- Platform fees: Blue Guardian allows the use of Tradovate, ProjectX, and Volsys. BrightFunded supports NinjaTrader and TradingView.
What mistakes cost you
In prop trading, the cost of a mistake is measured by how much it costs to try again and how easily the rules are triggered.
- Resets: If you fail an evaluation, Blue Guardian offers a 30% discount on the reset. BrightFunded charges 55% of the current list price, making failures more expensive.
- Drawdown type: Blue Guardian uses End-of-Day (EOD) drawdown on all plans. This is "cheaper" for the trader as it doesn't penalize unrealized intraday profits. BrightFunded Plus uses intraday trailing drawdown (the most expensive type for the trader's nerves and wallet), while their Core plan uses EOD.
- Daily Loss Limit (DLL): Blue Guardian uses a "soft breach" system. If you hit the daily limit, the account is merely paused until the next day. BrightFunded does not have a separate daily limit, meaning you only lose the account if you hit the max drawdown.
What it costs to get paid
Getting your money out also has a price tag in terms of percentages and waiting times.
- Profit Split: Blue Guardian is more generous, offering a flat 90%. BrightFunded starts at 80%, and reaching 100% requires an upfront surcharge.
- Withdrawal Fees: Blue Guardian charges a 2% processing fee via Riseworks.
- The "Buffer" Cost: BrightFunded Plus requires you to keep a mandatory buffer (Initial balance + MLL + $100) in the account before you can withdraw. Blue Guardian Reserve has no buffer, allowing you to withdraw profits sooner, although the drawdown floor locks at the starting balance + $100 after the first payout.
- Consistency rules: Both firms use consistency rules (40-50% for Blue Guardian; 40-50% for BrightFunded evaluations) that act as a "time tax," preventing you from passing or withdrawing in a single lucky day.
Where each one hides its cost
Blue Guardian hides its costs in the transition to Live. While the evaluation is cheap, the professional phase includes deductions for CME data and platform fees that are not present in the demo phase. There is also a $500 minimum withdrawal limit across all accounts.
BrightFunded hides its costs in the "Add-ons." To get conditions comparable to other firms (like a high profit split or a decent payout cap), the final price of the challenge can almost double. Additionally, the intraday drawdown on their "Plus" plan is a hidden trap that increases the statistical probability of failure.
Cheapest for whom
- For the budget-conscious beginner: Blue Guardian is the winner. The $100 entry for a $50k account and the 30% reset discount provide the most attempts for the least money.
- For the high-frequency scalper: Blue Guardian is cheaper because it lacks the 15-second minimum duration rule that BrightFunded enforces.
- For the long-term professional: BrightFunded might be worth the higher cost due to its "Prime Program," which offers bonuses of up to $30,000 for consistency and the eventual move to real capital.
Frequently asked questions
Which firm is cheaper to start a $50,000 evaluation, Blue Guardian or BrightFunded?
Blue Guardian is significantly cheaper. Its Reserve evaluation for $50,000 costs $100, while the most affordable equivalent at BrightFunded (the BrightPlus plan) costs $165. This makes Blue Guardian 39% cheaper at the point of entry.
Who has a more expensive reset, Blue Guardian or BrightFunded?
BrightFunded is more expensive to reset. They charge 55% of the full list price of the challenge. In contrast, Blue Guardian offers a 30% discount on the original price for evaluation resets, allowing traders to restart their journey with a smaller financial burden.
Which firm offers a better profit share, Blue Guardian or BrightFunded?
Blue Guardian offers a better standard deal with a 90% profit split on all funded accounts. BrightFunded starts with an 80% split, and while you can increase this to 100%, it requires paying a 20% surcharge on the initial challenge price.
Which firm is more restrictive for scalpers, Blue Guardian or BrightFunded?
BrightFunded is much more restrictive due to its "minimum trade duration" rule, which requires that 50% of winning profits come from trades held for at least 15 seconds. Blue Guardian allows scalping without a specific time minimum, only prohibiting "microscalping" (trades held for only a few seconds with minimal margins).






















