What you are signing up for
A prop firm evaluation is a test where you trade with virtual money to prove you can be profitable. If you pass, the firm allows you to trade their capital and keep a percentage of the gains.
Blue Guardian Futures offers three main evaluation paths (Standard, Reserve, and Express) and a "Direct" option. Direct is an instant funding model where you pay a higher fee (starting at $307 for a $25,000 account) to skip the test and start earning immediately. Their standard evaluations are cheaper, such as the $50,000 Reserve account for $100.
Halcyon Trader Funding focuses on three programs: Lite, Prime, and Dynamic. The Dynamic model is unique because you pay a very low initial fee ($47 or $49 for a $50,000 test) and only pay an "upgrade fee" if you actually pass the evaluation. This reduces your upfront risk if you are still learning.
Neither firm currently offers a free trial, which is a limited-time demo account used to practice before paying for the real test.
How hard each one is
The difficulty is defined by the "drawdown," which is the maximum amount you are allowed to lose before the account is closed.
Blue Guardian Futures uses an "End-of-Day (EOD) Trailing Drawdown." "Trailing" means the loss limit follows your highest balance; if you make $1,000, your floor moves up $1,000. Because it is EOD, it only calculates this at the end of the trading day, which is more forgiving for beginners. They also have a "Soft Breach" Daily Loss Limit. This is a safety net where, if you lose too much in one day, they simply close your trades and disable the account until the next day instead of failing you permanently.
Halcyon Trader Funding offers more variety. Their Lite plan uses an "Intraday Trailing Drawdown," which moves up in real-time as you make profit during a trade. This is much harder because a trade that goes up and then back down can "pull" your drawdown floor higher, leaving you with less room. Their Prime plan uses the easier EOD model. Unlike Blue Guardian, Halcyon does not have daily loss limits, meaning you only fail if you hit the overall maximum loss.
How long it takes
To pass, you must reach a "profit target," which is a specific amount of money you need to earn.
At Blue Guardian Futures, the target is usually 6%. You can pass the Standard evaluation in just one day if you reach the goal. The Express plan usually requires a 40% consistency rule, meaning no single day can account for too much of your total profit.
Halcyon Trader Funding allows you to pass the Lite or Dynamic evaluations in just 1 trading day. The Prime evaluation requires a minimum of 3 days. However, Halcyon has a "1-Day Pass" add-on for Prime that you can buy to remove this wait.
Where beginners fail
Most beginners fail due to the "consistency rule." This rule ensures you didn't just get lucky on one trade.
In Blue Guardian Futures, the rule is 40%. If you need to make $3,000, no single day can contribute more than $1,200 (40%) to that goal. If it does, you simply have to keep trading until that big day becomes a smaller percentage of your total.
Halcyon Trader Funding applies a 40% consistency rule to their Prime accounts and some Dynamic options. Beginners also struggle with Halcyon's "Minimum Daily Profit" once they are funded. To count a day toward your withdrawal, you must earn a minimum amount (like $200 on a 50K account), which adds pressure to perform every day.
What happens if you make it
Once you are "funded" (operating a live-simulated account), you can request a "payout" or withdrawal of your profits.
Blue Guardian Futures offers a 90% "profit split," meaning you keep $90 for every $100 earned. They process payouts very quickly, often within 24 business hours. If they are late, they give you an extra 10% of your share as a penalty. The minimum you can withdraw is $500.
Halcyon Trader Funding also offers a 90% profit split. However, their system is more rigid. You must complete 6 "qualifying" trading days (days where you hit the minimum profit target) before each request. Their minimum withdrawal is lower at $250, making it easier to see your first dollars, but they cap the maximum you can take out in the first few months.
If it is your first time
Blue Guardian Futures is the better choice for a complete beginner. Their "Soft Breach" daily limit acts as a protective shield that prevents you from losing your account over a single bad day. Additionally, their use of EOD drawdown across all plans is much safer than the Intraday model found in Halcyon’s cheaper plans. While Halcyon's Dynamic plan is cheaper to start, the technical difficulty of Intraday trailing drawdown often leads to faster failures for those who haven't mastered trade management.
Frequently asked questions
Which firm is cheaper for a first $50,000 evaluation, Blue Guardian Futures or Halcyon Trader Funding?
Blue Guardian Futures charges $100 for its 50K Reserve account. Halcyon Trader Funding is cheaper initially if you choose the Dynamic evaluation ($47), but you must pay an additional upgrade fee once you pass. If you prefer a one-time payment for a standard evaluation, Blue Guardian Futures is more affordable than Halcyon's Lite 50K ($173).
Does Blue Guardian Futures or Halcyon Trader Funding have a more beginner-friendly drawdown?
Blue Guardian Futures is more beginner-friendly because it uses an End-of-Day (EOD) drawdown on all plans. This means your loss limit only updates at the close of the market. Halcyon Trader Funding uses an Intraday drawdown on its Lite plan, which tracks your profit in real-time and is much easier to trigger accidentally during a volatile trade.
Which firm has a lower minimum withdrawal, Blue Guardian Futures or Halcyon Trader Funding?
Halcyon Trader Funding has a lower minimum withdrawal of $250 across its accounts. Blue Guardian Futures requires you to have at least $500 in profit before you can request a payout. This makes Halcyon more accessible for traders who want to pull out small amounts of profit sooner.
Who pays faster after a profit request, Blue Guardian Futures or Halcyon Trader Funding?
Blue Guardian Futures is faster, promising to process payouts within 24 business hours and offering a 10% bonus if they fail to meet this deadline. Halcyon Trader Funding processes requests in the order they are received and can take up to 3 business days, plus you must first complete 6 qualifying trading days before even being eligible to ask for the money.






















