/
Login
Breaking
All news
Comparison · Forex

Trading styles allowed at Finotive and forTraders

Finotive offers a highly flexible entry with challenges starting at $25 and a unique 1% monthly salary for funded traders, utilizing MetaTrader 5 as its primary platform. forTraders provides a broader platform choice (MT5, cTrader, TradeLocker) and a "Pay After Pass" model where you only pay the full fee after succeeding, with a fixed 14-day payout cycle. While Finotive uses a "strike" system for soft breaches and balance-based drawdown, forTraders focuses on a loyalty program and trailing or static drawdowns depending on the chosen plan.

Updated on

Scalping and Intraday Trading

Both firms permit scalping, but the technical execution and risk management requirements differ significantly.

  • Finotive: Scalpers are well-served by the "Solo FX" experiment, which has no specific restrictions on trade duration or profit concentration. However, in standard challenges, traders must watch the "Notional Volume Limit." Exceeding the allowed exposure for your account size results in a strike.
  • forTraders: Manual scalping is allowed, but there is a mandatory minimum hold time of 5 seconds per trade. "Tick scalping" and HFT (High-Frequency Trading) are strictly prohibited.
  • Risk and Cost: Finotive’s commissions are competitive ($2.50 to $5 per lot for Forex), while forTraders charges a flat $3 per lot on Forex, Metals, and Energies.

Swing Trading and Weekend Holding

The ability to hold positions over the weekend is a major point of divergence between these two brokers.

  • forTraders: This firm is much friendlier to swing traders. Weekend holding is unrestricted across all account types, allowing you to maintain positions without extra fees or special permissions.
  • Finotive: On Instant Funding accounts, you must purchase a "Weekend Holding Add-On" (20% of the account fee) to keep positions open. Without it, all non-crypto trades must be closed by Friday at 17:00 NY. Solo FX and Challenges do not explicitly list a weekend restriction, but for Instant accounts, a breach results in a strike and a reduction of the payout to 10%.
  • Platforms: forTraders offers cTrader, which is often preferred by swing traders for its advanced limit order management.

Automated Trading (EAs)

If you rely on algorithms, the choice depends on whether you built the tool yourself or bought it.

  • Finotive: Prohibits EAs entirely on the "Solo FX" accounts. On other programs, they allow custom-made EAs but strictly ban mass-market "plug-and-play" systems.
  • forTraders: Has a more restrictive policy regarding autonomy. EAs are only allowed as "decision-support tools" (for alerts, partial management, or predefined rules). Fully autonomous trading bots that trade without human intervention are prohibited.
  • Interactions: Finotive’s allowance for custom EAs is limited by their "Notional Volume" table; an EA that opens many large positions simultaneously might trigger a strike even if the strategy is sound.

News Trading

Operating during high-volatility events is permitted but governed by different safety buffers.

  • Finotive: Generally allows news trading. However, there is a noted contradiction in the Solo FX rules: the dashboard prohibits "straddling" (placing pending orders on both sides), but the official Schedule 10A-1 suggests this rule might be waived. Traders should confirm with support before high-impact events.
  • forTraders: Imposes a strict "no-trade zone" for Forex. You cannot open new positions within 5 minutes before or after high-impact news. You may, however, hold existing positions through the event.

Copy Trading and Hedging

  • Finotive: Allows both copy trading and hedging. This makes it a viable option for traders managing multiple accounts or using hedging as a risk management strategy.
  • forTraders: Prohibits "inbound" copy trading (copying from external sources to your forTraders account). Only "outbound" copying is allowed. Cross-account hedging (opening opposing positions on the same instrument across different accounts) is strictly forbidden.

If you trade like this

  • The Manual Scalper: Finotive (especially Solo FX) is superior because it lacks the 5-second minimum hold rule found at forTraders.
  • The Swing Trader: forTraders is the clear winner as it allows weekend holding by default on all accounts without the 20% surcharge required by Finotive.
  • The Platform Enthusiast: forTraders is better, offering cTrader and TradeLocker in addition to MT5, whereas Finotive is limited to MT5.
  • The Algo Trader: Finotive is the better choice for custom-built EAs, as forTraders limits bots to "support only" and bans full autonomy.

Frequently asked questions

Which firm is cheaper to start a small account, Finotive or forTraders?

For the smallest possible entry, Finotive is cheaper with its $2,500 challenge at $25; the $6,000 "Forex Fast" challenge at forTraders costs $49. However, forTraders also offers a "Pay After Pass" model where you pay only $29 initially for a $25,000 account, though you must pay a $189 activation fee after passing.

Can I use a commercial EA on both Finotive and forTraders?

No. forTraders prohibits fully autonomous bots entirely, limiting EAs to support tools. Finotive allows EAs but strictly prohibits "mass-market" or "plug-and-play" commercial systems. If your EA is a common one bought online, it will likely be flagged and banned on both platforms.

Who pays faster and more reliably, Finotive or forTraders?

Finotive offers the potential for faster payouts, with the first request available on demand and subsequent cycles as short as 7 days for Standard and Pro challenges. forTraders has a fixed 14-day cycle but provides a "48-hour payout guarantee"; if they fail to pay within 48 hours of approval, the trader receives a 100% profit split for that cycle.

Which firm has stricter rules for holding trades over the weekend, Finotive or forTraders?

Finotive is significantly stricter. On their Instant accounts, you must pay an extra 20% fee to hold over the weekend; otherwise, you risk a strike that reduces your payout to 10%. In contrast, forTraders allows weekend holding on all account types with no extra costs or restrictions.

Field by field

Finotive and forTraders, side by side

Rules, plans, platforms, leverage, commissions and payouts of both, with the option to see only what differs.

Head to head

57 differences

Headquarters

Innovation One Building, Level 2, DIFC, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

Goldcrest Executive Building, Office No. 1210, JLT, Cluster C, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

CEO

Oliver Newland

Jakub Rož

Country

United Arab Emirates

United Arab Emirates

Foundation

2021

2023

Banned Countries
Iran, North Korea, United States
Pakistan, Iran, Syria, Myanmar, Bangladesh, North Korea, Russian Federation, Belarus, Cuba, Lebanon, Libya, Sudan, South Sudan, Crimea, Donetsk, Luhansk, United Arab Emirates
Assets
Forex, Indices, Commodities, Crypto
Forex, Commodities, Indices, Crypto
Brokers
Finotive Markets

Liquidity Provider

Refund
Yes

Full refund if profitable 30 days after funding.

Solo FX: The Dashboard and launch announcement say the fee is refunded after 30 funded days if the account is profitable. Schedule 10A-1 says it is refunded upon approval of the first Reward Payment Request. Finotive's Terms state that the Schedule prevails; confirm with support before purchase.

Yes

Pay After Pass: pay activation fee only after passing. No traditional refund.

Payout Fee
No data
  • Crypto ($100 to $399): $25
  • Rise ($400 or more): $50
Platforms
Metatrader 5
Metatrader 5, cTrader, TradeLocker
Demo Account
Metatrader 5
ID1043PasswordFinotiveServerFinotiveMarkets-Live
No data
Payout Methods
Transfer, Crypto, Revolut
Transfer, Crypto, Rise
Payment Methods
Card, Crypto, Transfer, UPI
Card, Crypto, Transfer
Payout Frequency

First payout on demand

  • Standard Challenge, Pro Challenge and Instant Standard: 7 days
  • Instant Lite: 14 days
  • Solo FX: weekly payouts; first request after 14 calendar days in Simulated Funded Status

Every 14 days. Pay After Pass: on demand.

Payout Guarantee
No data

48 hours: if not paid within 48h, 100% profit split

Crypto Weekend Trading
No data
Yes
Minimum Withdrawal

$4

  • Minimum: $100 in For Traders wallet
  • Maximum per cycle (bi-weekly): $15,000 on most accounts
  • Withdrawal fees:
    · $100-$399 (crypto): $25
    · $400+ (Rise: bank/local/crypto): $50
Instruments
No data
Forex (majors, minors, exotics), Commodities (CFDs), Indices (CFDs), Energies (CFDs), Metals (CFDs), Crypto (top 5 CFD pairs)
Forex
  • 2-Step Standard, 2-Step Pro: 100:1
  • 1-Step Standard, 1-Step Pro: 50:1
  • Instant Standard: 33:1
  • Instant Lite: 25:1
  • Solo FX (main Challenge range): up to 100:1
  • Solo FX Launchpad accounts: 33:1 until updated
  • Challenge accounts (evaluation phase): 1:125
  • Master accounts (Fast/Classic): 1:30
  • Master accounts (Fast Static): 1:20
  • Master accounts (Instant Pro): 1:10
  • Forex Instant: 1:30
Metals
  • 2-Step Standard, 2-Step Pro: 20:1
  • 1-Step Standard, 1-Step Pro: 10:1
  • Instant Standard, Instant Lite: 5:1
  • Challenge: 1:40 (gold/silver part of FX leverage 1:125)
  • Master: 1:10
Indices
  • 2-Step Standard, 2-Step Pro: 10:1
  • 1-Step Standard, 1-Step Pro, Instant Standard, Instant Lite: 5:1
  • Challenge: 1:20
  • Master: 1:10
  • Instant Pro: 1:5
  • Fast Static: 1:10
Stocks
  • 2-Step Standard, 2-Step Pro: 5:1
  • 1-Step Standard, 1-Step Pro: 4:1
  • Instant Standard, Instant Lite: 2:1
No data
Crypto
  • 2-Step Standard, 2-Step Pro: 2:1
  • 1-Step Standard, 1-Step Pro, Instant Standard, Instant Lite: 1:1

BTCUSD, ETHUSD and the other top crypto pairs: 1:2 on forex accounts.

Energies
No data
  • Challenge: 1:40
  • Master: 1:10
Forex
0
3 / lot
Metals
0
3 / lot
Energies
0
3 / lot
Indices
0
0
Stocks
0
No data
Crypto
0
25 / lot
Commission-Free Option
No data
No
Swap Free
Yes
No
Account Reset

Funded Stage Refresh

  • A refresh can only be requested when your account balance is within 10% of the Maximum Drawdown limit
  • Resets your account balance back to the original starting equity
  • Preserves your profit split rate and any progress made in the Scaling Plan
  • There is a maximum of 3 refreshes per funded account
  • The price depends on the size of the account
No data
Add-ons
Yes
  • Swap Free (price depends on the size of the account)
  • Weekend Holding for Instant Accounts (20% of account fee)
No
Instant
Yes
Yes
One Step
Yes
  • Standard Challenge
  • Pro Challenge
Yes
Account scaling
Yes

Every 90 days, traders who meet performance and consistency targets see their account balance grow by 30% and their profit split increase by 5%, without ever having to sacrifice withdrawals.

More detail about it can be found on this link

Yes

Scaling unlocked through the Loyalty Program (5 tiers: Starter, Rising Star, Pro, VIP, Legend). Increments depend on tier. Applies to all account types.

Two Steps
Yes
  • Standard Challenge
  • Pro Challenge
Yes
Max Drawdown

Static

  • Forex Fast: 6% trailing
  • Forex Fast Static: 6% balance-based static
  • Forex Classic: 8% or 10% (depending on order)
  • Forex Pay After Pass: 6% trailing
  • Forex Instant: 5% trailing
  • Forex Instant Pro: 6% trailing
Profit Split
  • Standard Challenge: 80% (up to 95% scaling)
  • Pro Challenge: 100%
  • Instant Standard: 75% (up to 90%)
  • Instant Lite: 70% (up to 85%)
  • Forex evaluation products (Fast, Fast Static, Classic and Pay After Pass): 80% or according to the selected order
  • Forex Instant: starts at 70% and increases by 5% with each reward, up to 90%
  • Forex Instant Pro: starts at 60% and increases by 10% with each reward, up to 90%
Free Trial
Yes
No
Daily Drawdown

Balance-based

  • Forex Fast/Fast Static/Pay After Pass: 3% (Fast: from previous day equity; Fast Static: from previous day balance/equity)
  • Forex Classic: 4% or 3% (depending on order)
  • Forex Instant: 3% of starting balance
  • Forex Instant Pro: none
Three Steps
No
No
Max Allocation
  • Challenge Accounts (Standard): Up to $600,000 in purchased capital, scalable to $2,040,000
  • Pro Challenge Accounts: Up to $600,000 in purchased capital, scalable to $2,040,000
  • Instant Funding (Standard): Up to $200,000 in purchased capital, scalable to $680,000
  • Instant Funding Lite: Up to $200,000 in purchased capital, scalable to $680,000

$300,000 combined across all Master Accounts and Instant Models (Forex + Crypto + Futures shared cap). No allocation limit during Challenge phase.

Merge Accounts
No
No
Maximum Trading Days
No data

No limit

Monthly Competition
No
Yes
Minimum Profitable Days

Minimum profitable days number must be met every time a trader wants to pass an evaluation phase, scale a funded account or request a payout. A day is considered profitable when it reaches at least 0.5% profit

  • Challenge 1 Step: 3 days
  • Challenge 2 Step: 2 days
  • Instant Standard: 0 days
  • Instant Lite: 5 days
  • Finotive Pro 1 Step: 3 days
  • Finotive Pro 2 Step: 2 days
  • Solo FX: 4 days with at least 0.5% each
  • Forex Fast: 3 profitable days (0.5% of starting balance each)
  • Forex Fast Static: 3 profitable days
  • Forex Pay After Pass: not required
  • Forex Classic: 3 profitable days per phase
  • Forex Instant: 7 profitable days
  • Forex Instant Pro: not required
Expert Advisor (EA)
Limited
  • Solo FX: all Expert Advisors and automated execution tools are prohibited
  • Other programmes: pre-purchased or mass-market “plug-and-play” EAs are not allowed
No

EAs allowed only as decision-support tools (alerts, partial management, predefined rules). Fully autonomous trading bots are prohibited.

VPN
Limited
  • Solo FX: VPNs, proxies and location masking are prohibited
  • Other programmes: Finotive's Terms prohibit masked or unstable connections when they impair verification of identity, location or account control
Yes
Hedging
Yes
No

Cross-account hedging (opposing positions on the same instrument across accounts) is forbidden.

Requires Stop Loss
Limited
  • Solo FX: stop loss is not required
  • Other programmes: stop loss is required
No
Scalping
Limited

Accounts with the unified High-Frequency Trading rule active: up to 20% of profit may come from trades held for two minutes or less. The rule becomes active after the first 10 closed trades and is tracked in the dashboard. Exceeding the limit does not generate a strike, but the percentage must return within 20% before requesting a payout.

Solo FX has no specific scalping, rapid-trade-opening, trades-under-60-seconds or HFT restriction. Latency arbitrage and execution abuse remain prohibited.

Yes

Manual scalping allowed with a minimum 5-second hold per trade. Tick scalping and HFT are forbidden.

Stacking / Layering (DCA)
No
Yes
Martingale
No data
No

Martingale strategies (doubling position size after losses) are classified as gambling and forbidden.

Maximum Risk Limit
Yes

Floating drawdown is calculated per symbol against the initial account balance.

  • Instant Funding: 1.5%. The first confirmed breach produces a formal warning. From the second confirmed breach onward, each separate event records one strike and reduces that payout cycle's reward payment to 10%.
  • Funded Challenge and Funded Pro: 2%. Each confirmed breach records one strike and reduces that payout cycle's reward payment to 10%.
  • Challenge and Pro evaluation phases: 2%. It is monitored for the progression report but does not trigger a real-time strike or account closure.
  • Solo FX: 2.5% during Simulated Funded Status only. A confirmed breach records one strike and reduces that payout cycle's reward payment to 10%.
Yes

Open trades: maximum 3% risk on a single position.

Copy Trading
Yes
No

Outbound copy trading (from your For Traders account to external accounts) is allowed. Inbound copy trading from external sources is strictly forbidden.

News Trading
Yes

News trading is allowed. For Solo FX, the Dashboard and launch announcement prohibit news straddling, but Schedule 10A-1 disapplies the Terms section that prohibits it. Confirm this contradiction with Finotive before trading news.

Limited

Free during the challenge. On the Master account, no new positions within 5 minutes before/after high-impact news events. Existing positions can be held through news.

Inactivity Rule

30 days

  • Forex Fast / Fast Static / Classic / Pay After Pass (Challenge & Master): 30 days
  • Forex Instant / Instant Pro: 7 days

Days counted from the moment a position is CLOSED, not opened. Minimal 0.01-lot trades to game the rule don't count.

Consistency Rule
Yes

Pro accounts — from the 31st funded day

  • Weekly trade count and instrument volume must remain within ±25% of the averages recorded during the Pro Challenge and the first 30 funded days.
  • During every rolling 90-day period, realised and unrealised profit, including rewards already paid, must total at least 5% of the initial balance.
  • Breaching either condition downgrades the account to the equivalent standard funded account and permanently removes the Pro benefits.

Instant Funding Standard and Lite

  • At payout, the single most profitable closed trade must contribute less than 60% of total positive realised profit. Requesting a payout while the condition remains active records one Conditional Strike and reduces that payout cycle's reward payment to 10%.
  • Overlapping positions on the same instrument and direction count as one combined position, and partial closures do not create separate positions. There are no one-sided trading limits and volume per instrument is not checked.

Solo FX

  • No specific consistency rule or single-trade profit dependency.
Yes
  • Forex Fast: no consistency rule on Challenge; consistency on Master varies.
  • Forex Pay After Pass Master: best day cannot exceed 20% of total profit.
  • Forex Instant: best day cannot exceed 15% of total profit.
  • General gambling rule: passing via a single trade exceeding 70% of profit target is forbidden.
Hold Weekend
Yes

Weekend holding is available through the optional Weekend Holding Add-On on Instant Funding accounts. Without it, all non-crypto positions must be closed before Friday's 17:00 New York market close; Finotive recommends closing at least 10 minutes earlier. Each confirmed breach records one strike and reduces that payout cycle's reward payment to 10%. Five cumulative strikes permanently close the account.

Yes

Weekend holds are unrestricted across all account types.

Prohibited Strategies
  • Excessive notional volume (not applicable to Solo FX; its exposure is governed by the margin requirement applicable to the account)
  • High-frequency stacking, including correlated instruments (not a Solo FX-specific restriction; latency arbitrage and execution abuse remain prohibited)
  • Martingale or grid strategies
  • News straddling (the Solo FX dashboard and announcement prohibit it, but Schedule 10A-1 disapplies section 7.9; confirm with support)
  • Using ultra-tight stops just to mask oversized lots
  • Arbitrage (latency, reverse, statistical)
  • HFT (High Frequency Trading)
  • Grid trading
  • Tick scalping
  • Fully autonomous bots/EAs
  • Cross-account hedging
  • Gambling behaviors (overleveraging, all-in trades > 70% of profit target)
  • Martingale
  • Inbound copy trading and signal services
  • Group/signal trading from Telegram, Discord etc.
Free newsletter

Pick your firms. Get what matters.

  • Exclusive promotions, updated daily
  • Funded trading industry news
  • Full control: you choose which firms to follow

FreeNo spamOne-click unsubscribe

Community

Join the community

Join us on our mission to become the most influential family in funded trading.

  • trade-ideasTrading ideas from the community
  • giveawaysGiveaways from prop firms
  • respect-leaderboardTop 10 by Respect earned
  • wins-and-lossesFundings, payouts and blown accounts
Join the Discord