Day one
The entry point for both firms focuses on evaluation efficiency and platform flexibility.
- Halcyon Trader Funding: Offers three distinct paths (Lite, Prime, and Dynamic).
- Pricing: One-time evaluation fee. For a $150K account, the Lite version costs $138 (plus a $163 activation fee later) or an all-in higher fee. There are no recurring subscriptions.
- Platforms: Broad compatibility including TradingView, Quantower, ATAS, and Volumetrica via Rithmic or Ironbeam.
- Rules: 1 to 3 minimum trading days depending on the plan. Prime requires 40% consistency, while Lite has no consistency rule for entry.
- TradeDay: Uses a subscription-based model (TradeDay 2.0) with no activation fees.
- Pricing: Monthly subscriptions. A $150K Fast Pass account typically costs $225/month.
- Platforms: Native integration with Tradovate, NinjaTrader, and TradingView.
- Rules: Quick Pay requires 5 trading days and 30% consistency. Fast Pass has no minimum trading days but requires 45% consistency.
The first months
Once the evaluation is passed, the focus shifts to withdrawal frequency and risk management.
- Halcyon Trader Funding:
- Payout Cycle: 6 qualifying trading days are required before each request. Each day must meet a minimum profit requirement ($350-$400 for a $150K account).
- Profit Split: 90/10 from the start.
- Withdrawal Caps: The first five rewards are capped (e.g., $3,000 max per reward for a $150K account).
- Risk: No daily loss limit. Drawdown locks at the starting balance + $100 after the first approved reward.
- TradeDay:
- Payout Cycle: Quick Pay allows withdrawals from day one with no buffer. Fast Pass requires 5 profitable days per payout.
- Profit Split: 80/20 in Sim. However, Quick Pay drops to 50/50 if the account has less than $4,000 in gross profit.
- Withdrawal Caps: Fast Pass Sim accounts have a maximum per-request limit (e.g., $2,250 for a $150K account).
- Risk: Trailing Maximum Drawdown (TMD) can be Intraday or End-of-Day depending on the purchased challenge.
El primer año
At the one-year mark, the goal is to move away from simulation into live environments and higher contract limits.
- Halcyon Trader Funding:
- Transition: After 5 rewards, traders are reviewed for the "Trader Live Training" (TLT) program, a bridge to a Live Brokerage account on Ironbeam.
- Scaling: There is no automatic position scaling in Sim, but Live accounts allow swing trading and have margin-based contract limits.
- Profit Split: Increases to 100% for the trader once in a Live Brokerage account.
- Portfolio: Traders can manage up to 3 active Reward accounts simultaneously.
- TradeDay:
- Transition: Successful Sim traders transition to "Funded Live" accounts.
- Scaling: Fast Pass accounts feature a structured scaling plan, starting with 4 contracts for $150K and adding one contract for every $2,000 in EOD profit.
- Profit Split: Increases to 90/10 in the Funded Live phase.
- Portfolio: Allows up to 5 active Funded Live accounts per trader.
The ceiling
The ultimate potential of these firms is defined by their capital allocation and trading freedom.
- Halcyon Trader Funding: The ceiling is defined by the Live Brokerage transition. Live account balances can reach up to 3X the size of the initial transition model. Because it is a real brokerage account, traders gain the freedom of swing trading (holding overnight/weekends) which is prohibited in all their Sim phases.
- TradeDay: The ceiling is focused on professional multi-account management. With the ability to hold 5 Live accounts and a scaling plan that grows contracts based on realized profit, the ceiling is dictated by the trader's ability to manage large clip sizes. TradeDay allows overnight holding in both Sim and Live, providing more strategic flexibility earlier than Halcyon.
Room to grow
Halcyon is better suited for traders who want a 100% profit split and a clear path to a regulated brokerage environment, though they must endure a very strict "day trading only" rule and withdrawal caps during the first few months. TradeDay offers a more professional scaling environment from the start, allowing overnight positions and providing a more robust educational/coaching infrastructure. While Halcyon's 100% split is the highest in the industry, TradeDay’s scaling plan and higher account limit (5 live accounts vs 3 reward accounts) offer a more traditional professional trajectory for those who don't mind the monthly subscription.
Frequently asked questions
Which firm is cheaper for a $50K evaluation, Halcyon or TradeDay?
Halcyon is generally cheaper for a one-time payment, offering a $50K Dynamic evaluation for $47 (Intraday) or $49 (EOD). TradeDay operates on a monthly subscription, with a $50K Fast Pass costing approximately $85 per month. However, TradeDay has no activation fees, whereas Halcyon Lite/Prime requires an activation fee (around $79 for a $50K account) after passing if you didn't choose the "all-in" pricing.
Does Halcyon or TradeDay allow holding positions over the weekend?
TradeDay allows holding positions overnight and through the weekend, provided the trader follows the specific margin and risk rules of the platform. Halcyon Trader Funding strictly prohibits overnight and weekend holding in all its evaluation and Reward (Sim) accounts; positions must be closed by 4:45 PM EST. Holding over the weekend is only an option for Halcyon traders who have successfully transitioned to a Live Brokerage account.
Who offers a better profit split, Halcyon or TradeDay?
Halcyon offers a higher profit split in the long run, starting at 90/10 in Sim accounts and rising to 100% once the trader reaches a Live Brokerage account. TradeDay starts with an 80/20 split in Sim accounts (which can be as low as 50/50 on Quick Pay for profits under $4,000) and increases to 90/10 once the trader moves to a Funded Live account.
Which firm has stricter consistency rules, Halcyon or TradeDay?
The strictness depends on the chosen plan. Halcyon’s Prime plan has a 40% consistency rule, but their Lite plan has no consistency rule at all. TradeDay applies consistency rules to all evaluations: 30% for Quick Pay and 45% for Fast Pass. Furthermore, TradeDay's Fast Pass maintains the 45% consistency rule even in the Funded Sim phase, whereas Halcyon's consistency rule only applies to the qualifying period for each specific reward.



















