Scalping and High-Frequency Trading
Both firms allow manual scalping, but they have different technical environments and restrictions for this high-speed style.
- Platforms and Costs: Orion Funded uses MetaTrader 5 and Match-Trader, with commissions around $4 per lot for Forex and Metals. The Trading Pit offers MT4, MT5, and cTrader, with slightly higher commissions ($5 per lot) but allows scalping on its CFD Prime accounts, including trades lasting less than one minute.
- Restrictions: Orion strictly prohibits tick scalping and HFT. Any strategy exploiting simulated environment delays is a breach. The Trading Pit also bans HFT but is more explicit about allowing very short-term trades on specific account types.
- Risk Management: For scalpers at Orion, the 20% "Best Day" rule on Zero and Nova accounts prevents "all-in" scalp trades from making up the bulk of the profit. The Trading Pit applies a similar consistency rule (30% to 50% best day limit) depending on the account type.
Swing Trading and Weekend Holding
The ability to hold positions over the weekend and through volatility is a major divider between these two firms.
- Weekend Rules: Orion Funded is very flexible, allowing weekend holding across its accounts. The Trading Pit allows it on most instruments for Instant accounts, but specifically requires closing Gold, Oil, and Crypto positions before the weekend break.
- Drawdown Mechanism: Swing traders at Orion should prefer the Standard, Swing, or Select plans because they use static drawdown, which doesn't "eat" into unrealized profits. The Trading Pit uses static drawdown for most accounts, but some 1-Phase and 2-Phase large accounts (and Instant accounts) use trailing drawdown, which is riskier for long-term trades that fluctuate.
- Specific Accounts: Orion has a dedicated "Orion Swing" challenge with an 8% maximum drawdown and no news trading restrictions, making it the most optimized choice for this style.
News Trading
If you trade high-impact economic releases, you must pay close attention to the specific timing rules of each firm.
- Evaluation vs. Funded: At Orion, there are no news restrictions during the evaluation phase, but once funded, Standard, Select, and Nova accounts prohibit opening or closing trades 2 minutes before and after high-impact news. The "Swing" account has no restrictions, and the "Zero" account allows it but reduces the profit split to 50% for those specific trades.
- Account Size Limits: The Trading Pit allows news trading on most accounts, except for the $100,000 and $200,000 versions, which enforce a 2-minute "no-trade" window around high-impact releases.
- Strategy Ban: Orion explicitly states that using news as a primary strategy (news straddling/exploitation) is prohibited even if the timing is technically correct.
Automated Trading (EAs) and Copy Trading
Both firms are open to automation, but they require the trader to be the original author or owner of the strategy.
- EA Rules: Orion allows EAs as long as the strategy is the trader's own and doesn't use prohibited practices like latency arbitrage. The Trading Pit also allows EAs but bans grid and martingale strategies, which are common in many commercial bots.
- Copy Trading: Both firms allow you to copy trades between your own accounts within the same firm. However, both strictly prohibit copying third-party signals, external management services, or shared "community" EAs.
- Technical Setup: The Trading Pit’s inclusion of cTrader and MT4 provides more flexibility for traders who already have bots developed for those specific environments, whereas Orion is centered on MT5.
Hedging and Risk Coverage
Hedging is permitted but restricted to internal account management to prevent system manipulation.
- Internal vs. External: Orion allows hedging within a single account. However, it is strictly forbidden to hedge across multiple accounts (e.g., being long on one and short on another to "lock in" a passing grade).
- The Trading Pit Approach: Hedging is generally allowed. However, they prohibit "hedging-arbitrage," which usually refers to exploiting price differences between different feeds or servers.
- Stop Loss Requirement: A critical difference is that The Trading Pit requires a Stop Loss for all trades, whereas Orion Funded does not make it mandatory, though it is recommended for risk management.
If you trade like this
- If you are a Swing Trader: Orion Funded is the better choice, especially their "Swing" account which has no news restrictions and allows weekend holding with a static drawdown.
- If you are a Scalper: The Trading Pit is more attractive due to the availability of cTrader and its explicit permission for sub-one-minute trades on CFD Prime.
- If you use MT4 Bots: The Trading Pit is your only option here as Orion Funded has moved exclusively to MT5 and Match-Trader.
- If you want the lowest entry cost: Orion Funded offers $5,000 challenges starting at $49 and even a $10,000 Nova challenge for a $7 entry fee (plus activation), which is cheaper than The Trading Pit’s smallest $2,500 account for $29.
Frequently asked questions
Which firm is cheaper for a $50,000 challenge, Orion Funded or The Trading Pit?
Orion Funded is slightly cheaper for this size. An Orion Standard $50k challenge costs $329, while The Trading Pit’s 1-Phase and 2-Phase $50k challenges both cost $349. Additionally, Orion offers a 3-step "Select" version of the $50k account for $299 for those looking for the absolute lowest price.
Does Orion Funded or The Trading Pit have better payout conditions?
Orion Funded has more aggressive payout terms, offering a 48-hour processing guarantee (or you get 100% split) and no withdrawal fees. The Trading Pit also pays out every 14 days but charges a 1% payout fee on all withdrawals. Orion's initial split is 80%, rising to 90%, while The Trading Pit stays at 80% for most standard plans.
Which firm has stricter rules for News Trading, Orion Funded or The Trading Pit?
Orion Funded is generally stricter on funded accounts. In most Orion plans (except Swing), you cannot trade 2 minutes before or after news. At The Trading Pit, this restriction only applies to the large $100k and $200k accounts; smaller accounts at The Trading Pit can trade news freely without the 2-minute restriction.
Can I use a Martingale EA on Orion Funded or The Trading Pit?
Neither firm allows Martingale. Orion Funded explicitly lists Martingale as a prohibited rule in its "Rules" section. Similarly, The Trading Pit prohibits Martingale, Grid, and high-risk strategies in its "Prohibited Strategies" documentation. Both firms require that automated strategies be legitimate and not based on gambling or exploit behaviors.




















