/
Login
Breaking
All news
Comparison · Perps

Getting paid at Northbook and forTraders Perps

The fundamental difference between these two firms lies in their operational philosophy: while Northbook operates as a non-regulated entity with a proprietary B-book simulation that mirrors trades into the market at its discretion, forTraders Perps offers a more traditional prop environment but with a heavy focus on crypto-style perpetuals and specific growth hurdles before allowing a withdrawal.

Updated on

The split

Both firms start with a base 80% profit split for the trader. However, Northbook offers an optional "Split 90" add-on at checkout that permanently increases the share to 90% for the life of the account. at forTraders Perps, the 80% is fixed, although they offer a 100% split as a penalty guarantee if they fail to process a payout within 48 hours.

How often you can withdraw

Northbook is significantly more flexible, allowing withdrawals on demand with no waiting periods or frequency limits, provided all positions are closed. forTraders Perps also allows on-demand withdrawals from the first day on the Master account, but it imposes performance milestones: you must reach at least 1% profit on the initial balance for the first reward, and subsequently, the account must grow by 2% between withdrawals.

Minimums and methods

The barrier to exit is lower at Northbook, with a minimum withdrawal amount of only $20. They pay exclusively in USDC via smart contract, ensuring a verifiable transaction hash. A key detail is that Northbook does not allow partial withdrawals; each payout "sweeps" all profit above the starting balance.

forTraders Perps requires a minimum of $100 to move funds from their wallet. They offer Crypto and Rise as payment methods but charge fees: $25 for crypto payouts under $400, and $50 for Rise payments over $400. Additionally, forTraders limits rewards to $10,000 per request.

What delays a payout

At Northbook, the main delay is the identity verification process (photo ID and live selfie) and the strict risk limits. Their drawdown is static and equity-based; if you touch the limit (3%, 6%, or 8% depending on the plan), the account is closed instantly. There are no consistency rules, but hedging between different Northbook accounts or using HFT strategies will lead to disqualification.

forTraders Perps introduces more "soft" and "hard" hurdles. A payout can be delayed or profits deducted if you trade high-impact news on the Master account (5 minutes before and after). They also have an inactivity rule: you must close at least one position every 7 days or face a hard breach. Furthermore, their 5-second minimum hold time for scalping and the prohibition of martingale/grid strategies act as filters that can invalidate a trading session.

What it takes to get there

Both firms utilize 1-step evaluation models with no time limits and proprietary platforms.

  • Northbook: Offers three tiers (Base, Classic, Prime) with varying prices and drawdown allowances. For example, a $50,000 Base account costs $225 with a 3% drawdown, while the Prime version costs $750 but allows an 8% drawdown. It allows bots (excluding HFT) and has no minimum trading days.
  • forTraders Perps: Their "Perps Fast" model is generally more expensive for the drawdown offered. A $50,000 account costs $493 with a 5% drawdown. They are much stricter with automation, banning fully autonomous EAs and only allowing them as decision-support tools.

Which pays out more comfortably

Northbook is the better choice for traders who want immediate, friction-free access to their profits and use automated strategies, as long as they can handle a very tight static drawdown. The $20 minimum and lack of withdrawal fees make it ideal for frequent, small payouts.

forTraders Perps is more suitable for manual traders who prefer a slightly larger drawdown cushion (5% vs Northbook's 3% Base) and don't mind the growth milestones (1-2%) in exchange for a more structured environment that includes news trading restrictions and mandatory activity.

Frequently asked questions

Which firm is cheaper to start a $50,000 challenge, Northbook or forTraders Perps?

Northbook is significantly cheaper for a $50,000 account, with its "Base" plan costing $225 compared to the $493 charged by forTraders Perps. However, it is important to note that the Northbook Base plan only allows a 3% total drawdown, whereas forTraders Perps offers a 5% cushion for that price.

Who has a lower minimum withdrawal limit, Northbook or forTraders Perps?

Northbook has a much lower limit, allowing traders to withdraw from just $20. In contrast, forTraders Perps requires a minimum of $100 in the platform wallet to process a withdrawal. Additionally, Northbook does not charge payout fees, while forTraders Perps applies fees ranging from $25 to $50 depending on the amount and method.

Which firm is more permissive with the use of EAs and bots, Northbook or forTraders Perps?

Northbook is more permissive as it allows the use of trading bots as long as they do not engage in high-frequency trading (HFT) or exploit market microstructure. forTraders Perps, on the other hand, strictly prohibits fully autonomous EAs, only allowing them as support tools for manual decision-making.

Which firm offers a higher maximum drawdown limit, Northbook or forTraders Perps?

Northbook offers a higher maximum drawdown of up to 8% in its "Prime" plans, although these come at a higher purchase price. forTraders Perps maintains a fixed static drawdown of 5% across its "Perps Fast" accounts. Both firms measure drawdown based on equity and treat a breach as a permanent account closure.

Field by field

forTraders Perps and Northbook, side by side

Rules, plans, platforms, leverage, commissions and payouts of both, with the option to see only what differs.

Head to head

48 differences

10%off · Exclusive
Headquarters

Goldcrest Executive Building, Office No. 1210, JLT, Cluster C, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

No data
CEO

Jakub Rož

No data
Country

United Arab Emirates

No data
Foundation

2023

No data
Banned Countries
Pakistan, Iran, Syria, Myanmar, Bangladesh, North Korea, Russian Federation, Belarus, Cuba, Lebanon, Libya, Sudan, South Sudan, Crimea, Donetsk, Luhansk, United Arab Emirates
CU, IR, KP
Assets
Crypto, Stocks, Indices, Commodities, Forex
Crypto, Stocks, Indices, Commodities, Forex
Brokers

No broker: prices come from Hyperliquid or Binance, whichever has more liquidity for each market.

No broker: in-house terminal showing Hyperliquid's live order book and prices. Orders are not sent to Hyperliquid: they fill in an internal simulation (B-book), and Northbook decides which accounts it mirrors into a live market.

Refund
No data
Limited

The fee is non-refundable once the account is activated. The Fee Rebate add-on returns it in full with your first payout.

Payout Fee
  • Crypto ($100 to $399): $25
  • Rise ($400 or more): $50

No withdrawal fee.

Platforms
For Traders Perps
Propietary Platform
Payout Methods
Crypto, Rise
Crypto
Payment Methods
Card, Crypto
Crypto
Payout Frequency

On demand from the first day on the Master account, with positions closed. First reward after 1% profit on the initial balance; then 2% growth on the remaining balance between rewards.

On demand, with no waiting period and no limit on requests. All positions and orders must be closed first, and identity verification must be complete (photo ID and a live selfie, no proof of address).

Payout Guarantee

48 hours: if not paid within 48h, 100% profit split

No guarantee with compensation. They pay in USDC by smart contract as soon as you request it, with a transaction hash you can check. They say they keep a public USDC vault of at least 15-20% of all funded capital.

Crypto Weekend Trading
Yes

Every market trades 24/7, weekends included: indices, gold and oil too.

Yes
Maximum Withdrawal

$10,000 per reward.

No cap. Each payout sweeps all profit above the starting balance: no partial withdrawals.

Minimum Withdrawal

$100 to withdraw from the For Traders wallet.

$20.

Metals

Gold: 20:1 in the help center, 10:1 in the instruments list. Silver, platinum, palladium and copper: 5:1.

Capped per pair, never above the maximum Hyperliquid allows for that pair. Each pair's cap is shown in the terminal and may change.

Energies

WTI and Brent: 8:1. Natural gas: 5:1.

Capped per pair, never above the maximum Hyperliquid allows for that pair. Each pair's cap is shown in the terminal and may change.

Indices

NAS100 and SP500: 12:1. JP225: 5:1.

Capped per pair, never above the maximum Hyperliquid allows for that pair. Each pair's cap is shown in the terminal and may change.

Stocks

NVDA, AAPL, MSFT, AMZN, META and GOOGL: 4:1. MSTR, COIN, CRCL, CRWV and BMNR: 2:1. Other stocks: 3:1.

Capped per pair, never above the maximum Hyperliquid allows for that pair. Each pair's cap is shown in the terminal and may change.

Crypto

BTC: 10:1. ETH: 8:1. BNB and SOL: 5:1. HYPE, DOGE, XRP, TRX and LIT: 3:1. Other crypto: 2:1.

Capped per pair, never above the maximum Hyperliquid allows for that pair. Each pair's cap is shown in the terminal and may change.

Forex
No data

Capped per pair, never above the maximum Hyperliquid allows for that pair. Each pair's cap is shown in the terminal and may change.

Forex
No data
0
Metals
No data
0
Energies
No data
0
Indices
No data
0
Stocks
No data
0
Crypto
No data
0
Swap Free
No

Fixed daily fee on position value, charged hourly and equal for longs and shorts: crypto 0.03%, forex 0.005%, other markets 0.015%.

No

Positions pay or receive Hyperliquid funding, which counts in your P&L and toward your limits.

Account Reset
No data
No

No resets: an account that breaches a limit is closed for good.

Add-ons
No data
Yes
  • Split 90: raises the split from 80% to 90% for the life of the account.
  • Fee Rebate: returns 100% of the fee with your first payout.

Chosen at checkout, independent of each other; their price is not public.

Instant
No
No
One Step
Yes
Yes
Two Steps
No
No
Max Drawdown

Static, measured from the initial balance, in the challenge and on the Master account. After the first reward the floor locks at the initial balance for good. Hard breach.

Static on the starting balance: set when the account is created and never moves, with profit or payouts. Measured on equity including open positions; touching it closes the account for good.

Profit Split

80%.

80%, or 90% with the Split 90 add-on.

Daily Drawdown

Hard breach, open positions included. A fixed share of the initial balance, subtracted at 00:00 server time (CET/CEST) from the higher of balance or equity.

A percentage of the closed balance at 00:00 UTC, recalculated daily. Measured on equity including open positions; touching it closes the account for good.

Three Steps
No
No
Max Allocation
No data

$200,000 in active capital at once, counting challenges and funded accounts together.

Maximum Accounts
No data

No maximum number: you can hold several accounts, of the same size or different products, as long as the total stays within $200,000.

Maximum Trading Days

No time limit.

No time limit.

Minimum Trading Days

None.

None: you can pass with a single trade.

Minimum Profitable Days

None.

None.

Expert Advisor (EA)
No

EAs allowed only as decision-support tools (alerts, partial management, predefined rules). Fully autonomous trading bots are prohibited.

Limited

Bots are not banned, but high-frequency trading designed to exploit market microstructure (quote stuffing, layering) is.

Hedging
No

Cross-account hedging (opposing positions on the same instrument across accounts) is forbidden.

Limited

Opening opposing positions on the same instrument across several Northbook accounts is prohibited.

Requires Stop Loss
No data
No
Scalping
Yes

Manual scalping allowed with a minimum 5-second hold per trade. Tick scalping and HFT are forbidden.

Yes
Martingale
No

Martingale strategies (doubling position size after losses) are classified as gambling and forbidden.

No data
Maximum Risk Limit
No data
No

No per-trade risk limit beyond the leverage caps.

Copy Trading
No

Outbound copy trading (from your For Traders account to external accounts) is allowed. Inbound copy trading from external sources is strictly forbidden.

Yes

Permitted, including between your own Northbook accounts.

News Trading
Limited

Free in the challenge. On the Master account, no new positions from 5 minutes before to 5 minutes after high-impact news; open positions can stay. Breaking it is a soft breach: those profits may be deducted.

Yes
Inactivity Rule
Yes

Close at least one position every 7 days, in the challenge and on the Master account. Breaking it is a hard breach.

No data
Consistency Rule
No
No
Hold Weekend
Yes

Positions can stay open overnight and over the weekend.

Yes
Prohibited Strategies
  • Arbitrage (latency, reverse, statistical)
  • HFT (High Frequency Trading)
  • Grid trading
  • Tick scalping
  • Fully autonomous bots/EAs
  • Cross-account hedging
  • Gambling behaviors (overleveraging, all-in trades > 70% of profit target)
  • Martingale
  • Inbound copy trading and signal services
  • Group/signal trading from Telegram, Discord etc.
  • Hedging across several Northbook accounts
  • Coordinated group trading with other traders
  • Sharing, selling or transferring the account
  • Identity fraud or multiple identities
  • Exploiting platform, feed or Hyperliquid defects
  • Latency arbitrage and tick sniping
  • Account cycling with maximum-risk bets
  • Wash trading or trades with no real market risk
  • Insider information and front-running
  • High-frequency trading, quote stuffing and layering
Free newsletter

Pick your firms. Get what matters.

  • Exclusive promotions, updated daily
  • Funded trading industry news
  • Full control: you choose which firms to follow

FreeNo spamOne-click unsubscribe

Community

Join the community

Join us on our mission to become the most influential family in funded trading.

  • trade-ideasTrading ideas from the community
  • giveawaysGiveaways from prop firms
  • respect-leaderboardTop 10 by Respect earned
  • wins-and-lossesFundings, payouts and blown accounts
Join the Discord