1. Business Foundation and Institutional Trust
- FundingPips was established in 2022, making it a more experienced entity in the current prop firm landscape. It operates under CEO Khaled Ayesh and maintains a high Trustpilot presence with over 44,000 reviews.
- Upcomers is a newer entrant (2023) led by Jakub Zeliska. A critical point for traders is that its Trustpilot profile is currently blocked, which significantly increases the "platform risk" compared to more established competitors.
- Both firms are headquartered in the United Arab Emirates (Dubai), but they have different banned country lists. Upcomers has a much more extensive list of restricted regions, including Russia, Pakistan, and Venezuela.
2. Evaluation Models and Capital Scaling
- FundingPips offers a streamlined selection: 1-step, 2-step, 2-step Pro, and Zero (Instant). Their max allocation is capped at $300,000 before scaling, focusing on quality over a massive variety of complex rules.
- Upcomers provides an extremely wide range of programs, from 0.5-step (Ash) up to 5-step (Eon) evaluations, plus various Instant Funding options. Their total capital cap is much higher at $1.5 Million.
- Scaling Logic:
- FundingPips uses a level-based system (1 to 5) that rewards payouts and profit consistency with capital increases and drawdown extensions.
- Upcomers offers a 35% balance increase every 4 months, but requires a specific 15% cumulative growth and multiple successful withdrawals within that period.
3. Drawdown Mechanics and Risk Shielding
- Drawdown Type:
- FundingPips uses Static Drawdown for 1 and 2-step accounts, which is generally more trader-friendly as the floor never moves up.
- Upcomers utilizes three different systems. Their Dynamic Risk Shield™ (trailing drawdown) is particularly aggressive as it follows the highest equity (including open trades). While it "locks" at the starting balance after reaching the profit target, it is much harder to manage during the initial growth phase than a static limit.
- Daily Reset:
- FundingPips calculates daily drawdown based on the end-of-day (EOD) high-watermark.
- Upcomers calculates it based on the higher of balance or equity at the 00:00 UTC reset.
4. Profit Splits and Withdrawal Restrictions
- Profit Split: Upcomers offers a nearly total 99% split, whereas FundingPips varies from 60% to 100% (with 90% being the standard for On-Demand payouts).
- The Payout Cap (Upcomers Risk): Upcomers imposes a progressive withdrawal cap. For the first payout, you can only withdraw 1% of the initial balance. This only becomes "unlimited" after the 8th successful payout.
- FundingPips Flexibility: FundingPips does not have a progressive cap on withdrawals, making it much more attractive for traders looking to extract significant capital early in their funded stage.
- Fees: Upcomers charges high payout fees ($19.90 + 2.49% for transfers or up to 30% for Crypto due to UAE liquidity issues). FundingPips maintains a flat $10 fee.
5. Trading Rules and Hard Breaches
- Expert Advisors (EAs): Both firms strictly prohibit EAs. Upcomers is even more restrictive, banning any form of automation, including partial entry/exit management.
- Risk per Trade:
- FundingPips has a 3% maximum loss per trade (idea) rule on funded accounts. Violating this is a hard breach (account closure).
- Upcomers has varying "Max Single Trade Loss" limits ranging from 1% to 3% depending on the account type. They also apply a 20% Best Day Rule (soft breach) which can delay payouts if a single day accounts for too much of the total profit.
- News Trading:
- FundingPips allows it during evaluations but restricts profits during news events on standard funded accounts (5-minute window) unless using the On-Demand model.
- Upcomers generally allows news trading but prohibits "straddling" (placing bracket orders just before releases).
6. Execution Platforms and Commissions
- Platforms: FundingPips offers MT5, MatchTrader, and cTrader. Upcomers adds TradeLocker and ByBit to that list, providing more options for those used to crypto-style interfaces.
- Commissions:
- FundingPips: $5 to $7 per lot on Forex and Metals.
- Upcomers: $5 per lot on Forex/Metals, but they offer several "commission-free" indices and stocks.
7. Summary and Recommendations
Choose FundingPips if:
- You prefer Static Drawdown over trailing/dynamic models.
- You want to withdraw your full profits immediately without waiting for 8 payout cycles to bypass a cap.
- You value a firm with a longer track record and verified public trust (Trustpilot).
- You trade Forex and want a standard 2-step evaluation with clear, traditional rules.
Choose Upcomers if:
- You are an extremely high-volume trader aiming for a $1.5M - $4M allocation.
- You want the highest possible profit split (99%) and are willing to deal with slow initial withdrawals.
- You prefer Swap-Free accounts as a default (standard on all Upcomers accounts).
- You want access to specific platforms like TradeLocker or sessions-based trading (24h/4h challenges).





















