Day one
The entry experience differs significantly in cost and technical freedom. GFT is generally more affordable; for example, a $100,000 2-Step "Goat" account costs $478, whereas an Upcomers $100,000 "Phoenix Classic" account is priced at $999.
Technically, the most decisive factor is the use of Expert Advisors (EAs). GFT allows them, making it the immediate choice for algorithmic traders. Upcomers strictly prohibits EAs, bots, and any form of automated trading, focusing exclusively on manual traders.
Regarding platforms, both firms offer modern options:
- Goat Funded Trader: MatchTrader, cTrader, TradeLocker, Volumetrica, and MetaTrader 5.
- Upcomers: TradeLocker, MetaTrader 5, MatchTrader, cTrader, and DXTrade.
The first months
Once funded, the "friction" of withdrawals becomes the main topic. Upcomers implements a payout cap that starts very low: your first withdrawal is capped at 1% of the initial balance, the second at 2%, and so on. It takes eight successful payouts to reach unlimited withdrawals. GFT also has a cap, but it is much more generous: 6% of the initial balance for the first two requests, becoming unlimited thereafter.
Risk management also differs:
- Goat Funded Trader: Uses a 2-minute rule for scalping (profits from shorter trades are removed) and a 1% profit cap on news trading. Most models use a static drawdown.
- Upcomers: Focuses on a "Best Day" rule (20% to 30% depending on the plan) and specific risk-per-trade limits (e.g., 3% on Phoenix Classic, 2% on Vanguard).
Regarding refunds, GFT returns the fee after the 4th payout. Upcomers offers a 200% refund of the challenge fee after the 3rd payout, provided no strategy violations occurred.
The first year
This is where the scaling programs define the trader's path. GFT uses a level-based system, while Upcomers uses a periodic growth model.
Goat Funded Trader Scaling (Level 4):
- Requirements: 6 months in the live phase and 15 successful payouts.
- Benefits: 50% capital increase, 95% profit split, and a monthly salary of $500 (for accounts over 100K).
- Drawdown: Both daily and maximum limits increase by 4%.
Upcomers Scaling:
- Requirements: Every 4 consecutive months with at least 15% cumulative growth and 2 completed withdrawals.
- Benefits: 35% increase in the initial balance per cycle.
- Ceiling: Maximum allocation can scale up to $4,000,000.
The ceiling
The real "roof" of these firms depends on whether you seek a high balance or high stability. GFT limits its standard allocation to $400,000, but it compensates with a 95% profit split and a fixed salary, making it a very stable professional environment for consistent traders.
Upcomers allows for a much higher total capital ($1.5M initial across accounts, scaling to $4M), but the path is slower due to the payout caps in the early stages and the strict manual trading rules. GFT allows merging accounts, while Upcomers does not explicitly offer this feature in its structured data, focusing instead on individual contract growth.
Room to grow
Goat Funded Trader offers a faster start with lower prices and more freedom for EAs, leading to a "professional trader" status with a salary within six months. Upcomers is a marathon; the first months are restricted by payout caps, but it offers the highest capital ceiling in the industry for those who can prove their manual edge over several years.
Frequently asked questions
Which firm is cheaper to start a $100,000 challenge, Goat Funded Trader or Upcomers?
Goat Funded Trader is significantly cheaper. Its 2-Step "Goat" challenge for $100,000 costs $478, while the equivalent 2-Step "Phoenix Classic" from Upcomers costs $999. Even GFT's "Standard" 2-step account ($628) remains more affordable than the Upcomers entry price.
Can I use Expert Advisors (EAs) on both Goat Funded Trader and Upcomers?
No. Goat Funded Trader allows the use of EAs and automated trading. In contrast, Upcomers strictly prohibits EAs, bots, and any form of automated or semi-automated trading; they only allow indicators for manual analysis.
Who has more restrictive withdrawal limits in the first month, Goat Funded Trader or Upcomers?
Upcomers is much more restrictive initially. Their first payout is capped at 1% of the initial balance, and the second at 2%. Goat Funded Trader allows you to withdraw up to 6% of the initial balance for each of your first two payouts, which is a significantly higher limit for a new funded trader.
Which firm offers the highest maximum capital through scaling, Goat Funded Trader or Upcomers?
Upcomers offers a much higher ceiling, allowing traders to scale their allocation up to $4,000,000. Goat Funded Trader, while offering attractive perks like a 95% profit split and a monthly salary, has a standard maximum allocation of $400,000.






















