/
Login
Breaking
All news
Comparison · Forex

Long-term growth: Goat Funded Trader vs. Upcomers

Choosing between Goat Funded Trader (GFT) and Upcomers is a choice between two very different philosophies of professional growth. While one prioritizes flexibility and fixed rewards, the other focuses on a slow but massive capital climb.

Updated on

Day one

The entry experience differs significantly in cost and technical freedom. GFT is generally more affordable; for example, a $100,000 2-Step "Goat" account costs $478, whereas an Upcomers $100,000 "Phoenix Classic" account is priced at $999.

Technically, the most decisive factor is the use of Expert Advisors (EAs). GFT allows them, making it the immediate choice for algorithmic traders. Upcomers strictly prohibits EAs, bots, and any form of automated trading, focusing exclusively on manual traders.

Regarding platforms, both firms offer modern options:

  • Goat Funded Trader: MatchTrader, cTrader, TradeLocker, Volumetrica, and MetaTrader 5.
  • Upcomers: TradeLocker, MetaTrader 5, MatchTrader, cTrader, and DXTrade.

The first months

Once funded, the "friction" of withdrawals becomes the main topic. Upcomers implements a payout cap that starts very low: your first withdrawal is capped at 1% of the initial balance, the second at 2%, and so on. It takes eight successful payouts to reach unlimited withdrawals. GFT also has a cap, but it is much more generous: 6% of the initial balance for the first two requests, becoming unlimited thereafter.

Risk management also differs:

  • Goat Funded Trader: Uses a 2-minute rule for scalping (profits from shorter trades are removed) and a 1% profit cap on news trading. Most models use a static drawdown.
  • Upcomers: Focuses on a "Best Day" rule (20% to 30% depending on the plan) and specific risk-per-trade limits (e.g., 3% on Phoenix Classic, 2% on Vanguard).

Regarding refunds, GFT returns the fee after the 4th payout. Upcomers offers a 200% refund of the challenge fee after the 3rd payout, provided no strategy violations occurred.

The first year

This is where the scaling programs define the trader's path. GFT uses a level-based system, while Upcomers uses a periodic growth model.

Goat Funded Trader Scaling (Level 4):

  • Requirements: 6 months in the live phase and 15 successful payouts.
  • Benefits: 50% capital increase, 95% profit split, and a monthly salary of $500 (for accounts over 100K).
  • Drawdown: Both daily and maximum limits increase by 4%.

Upcomers Scaling:

  • Requirements: Every 4 consecutive months with at least 15% cumulative growth and 2 completed withdrawals.
  • Benefits: 35% increase in the initial balance per cycle.
  • Ceiling: Maximum allocation can scale up to $4,000,000.

The ceiling

The real "roof" of these firms depends on whether you seek a high balance or high stability. GFT limits its standard allocation to $400,000, but it compensates with a 95% profit split and a fixed salary, making it a very stable professional environment for consistent traders.

Upcomers allows for a much higher total capital ($1.5M initial across accounts, scaling to $4M), but the path is slower due to the payout caps in the early stages and the strict manual trading rules. GFT allows merging accounts, while Upcomers does not explicitly offer this feature in its structured data, focusing instead on individual contract growth.

Room to grow

Goat Funded Trader offers a faster start with lower prices and more freedom for EAs, leading to a "professional trader" status with a salary within six months. Upcomers is a marathon; the first months are restricted by payout caps, but it offers the highest capital ceiling in the industry for those who can prove their manual edge over several years.

Frequently asked questions

Which firm is cheaper to start a $100,000 challenge, Goat Funded Trader or Upcomers?

Goat Funded Trader is significantly cheaper. Its 2-Step "Goat" challenge for $100,000 costs $478, while the equivalent 2-Step "Phoenix Classic" from Upcomers costs $999. Even GFT's "Standard" 2-step account ($628) remains more affordable than the Upcomers entry price.

Can I use Expert Advisors (EAs) on both Goat Funded Trader and Upcomers?

No. Goat Funded Trader allows the use of EAs and automated trading. In contrast, Upcomers strictly prohibits EAs, bots, and any form of automated or semi-automated trading; they only allow indicators for manual analysis.

Who has more restrictive withdrawal limits in the first month, Goat Funded Trader or Upcomers?

Upcomers is much more restrictive initially. Their first payout is capped at 1% of the initial balance, and the second at 2%. Goat Funded Trader allows you to withdraw up to 6% of the initial balance for each of your first two payouts, which is a significantly higher limit for a new funded trader.

Which firm offers the highest maximum capital through scaling, Goat Funded Trader or Upcomers?

Upcomers offers a much higher ceiling, allowing traders to scale their allocation up to $4,000,000. Goat Funded Trader, while offering attractive perks like a 95% profit split and a monthly salary, has a standard maximum allocation of $400,000.

Field by field

Goat Funded Trader and Upcomers, side by side

Rules, plans, platforms, leverage, commissions and payouts of both, with the option to see only what differs.

Head to head

48 differences

90%off · Exclusive
Headquarters

The Sotheby Building, Ground Floor, Rodney Village, Rodney Bay, Gros-Islet, SW18 1TA, St. Lucia

Building A1, IFZA Business Park, Dubai Silicon Oasis, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

Country

St. Lucia

United Arab Emirates

Foundation

2023

2023

Banned Countries
Russia, Cuba, Sudan, Somalia, Iran, Lebanon, Syria, North Korea, Libya, Vietnam
Afghanistan, Central African Republic, Crimea, Donetsk and Luhansk regions of Ukraine, Cuba, Iran, Iraq, Kosovo, Libya, Mali, Myanmar, North Korea, Palestine, Russia, Somalia, South Sudan, Sudan, Syria, Vanuatu, Venezuela
CEO
No data

Jakub Zeliska

Assets
Forex, Indices, Commodities, Crypto
Forex, Commodities, Indices, Stocks, Crypto
Brokers

Liquidity Providers

Royal Flow - FZCO
Refund
Yes

Full refund after 4th payout

Yes

200% Challenge fee refund after the 3rd fully approved payout on Challenge accounts (Ash, Thunderbolt and Phoenix). The trader must request it through support. A partially approved payout or a payout with a strategy violation permanently disqualifies that account. It does not apply to Instant Funding accounts.

Platforms
MatchTrader, cTrader, TradeLocker, Volumetrica, MetaTrader5
TradeLocker, Metatrader 5, MatchTrader, cTrader, DX
Payout Methods
Transfer, Rise, Crypto
Crypto, Transfer
Payment Methods
ApplePay, Korapay, Card, GooglePay, PayPal, Crypto, Skrill, IMPS
Card, Crypto, PayPal, ApplePay, GooglePay, Skrill
Payout Frequency
  • Biweekly
  • Evaluation accounts can be purchased with an add-on to get the first payout On Demand with 40% profit split
  • Standard Instant Funding have 'Triple payday' rewards, allowing traders to withdraw profits every 10 days.
  • Instant Premium: every 10 days
  • Instant HERO: every 14 days
  • Instant Daily: first request 24 hours after purchase, then daily.
  • Withdrawal review by Risk Team: 24-48h (account trading is frozen during review).
  • Bank transfers: 2-5 business days after approval.
  • Crypto: faster, depends on blockchain network.
  • Other programs: minimum 1% profit required per payout (resets after each payout).
  • Turbo accounts: minimum 5 trading days per payout (each ≥0.5% profit).
  • Vanguard (Instant Funding): minimum 5 trading days per payout (each ≥0.5% profit).
  • Horizon and Odyssey: first payout 14 days after the funded account starts, then every 14 days. At least 3% profit of the initial balance is required before each payout, including between payouts, together with the required valid trading days.
Payout Guarantee

If the payout takes longer than promised (2 business days), the trader automatically receives an extra $500 reward, guarantee.

No data
Crypto Weekend Trading
Yes
Yes
Maximum Withdrawal

Other models: for the first two requests, up to 6% of the initial balance. Instant Daily: up to 3% of the initial balance per request.

Payout cap progresses with each approved withdrawal on the same funded account:

  • Payout #1: 1% of initial balance
  • Payout #2: 2%
  • Payout #3: 3%
  • Payout #4: 4%
  • Payout #5: 5%
  • Payout #6: 6%
  • Payout #7: account resets to initial balance with NO payout cap (unlimited from #8 onwards)
    Cap only increases after a FULLY approved withdrawal. Partial or declined payouts do not progress the cap.
Minimum Withdrawal

Other models: $100. Instant Daily: 1% of the initial balance per request.

No data
Payout Fee
No data
  • Bank Transfer (recommended): $19.90 + 2.49%.
  • Cryptocurrency: $19.90 + 30% (higher due to limited UAE crypto liquidity).
  • Returned payouts: $30 reprocessing fee (covers real bank/admin cost of reprocessing; not a penalty).
Demo Account
No data
Metatrader 5
ID1293766PasswordUpcomers1.ServerUpcomers-Server
Forex
  • Evaluation phases: 100:1
  • Funded phase: 50:1
100:1
Metals
  • Evaluation phases: 20:1
  • Funded phase: 10:1
30:1
Energies
  • Evaluation phases: 20:1
  • Funded phase: 10:1
30:1
Indices
  • Evaluation phases: 20:1
  • Funded phase: 10:1
30:1
Stocks
  • Evaluation phases: 5:1
  • Funded phase: 5:1
30:1
Crypto
  • Evaluation phases: 2:1
  • Funded phase: 2:1
30:1
Forex
5 / lot
5 / lot
Metals
5 / lot
5 / lot
Energies
0
0
Indices
0
0
Stocks
0
0
Crypto
0
0.04%
Commission-Free Option
No
No
Swap Free
No
Yes

All accounts are swap‑free

Account Reset

If you don’t complete a challenge, you can restart it at any time with a 12% discount. You’ll also get a single-use coupon that gives you 10% off any program.

Reset: buy a Reset to continue from the phase where you breached instead of starting over — it issues a new account at that phase (Funded reset gives a new Funded account, no re-evaluation). Available any time, or within 14 days of a breach. Each phase can be reset once. Price is a % of the original Challenge: Phase 1 −7%; Phase 2 +45–50%; Phase 3 +80%; Funded +50–175% (Instant: −7%).

Resets are offered as an alternative to full suspension after a rule violation. The account continues trading, but every future payout on that account is permanently capped at 50% of the approved amount.

Add-ons
Yes
  • Payout On Demand (+15%)
  • 100% Profit Split (+20%)
  • Both add-ons (+30%)
No
Instant
Yes
Yes
One Step
Yes
Yes
Account scaling
Yes
Yes

Scaling Plan for Thunderbolt and Vanguard accounts:

  • Apply every 4 consecutive months via help@upcomers.com.
  • +35% increase on simulated initial balance per cycle.
  • Maximum allocation scalable up to $4,000,000.
    Requirements per cycle:
  • ≥15% cumulative account growth across the 4 months.
  • ≥2 withdrawals completed in the 4-month period.
  • Final cycle must end in profit.
    Separate "4M on request" individual contract available after 6+ consecutive profitable months.
Two Steps
Yes
Yes
Max Drawdown
  • 1-Step, 2-Step: Static
  • Instant Funding: Trailing
  • Instant Premium: EOD high-watermark; not recalculated intraday or downward
  • Instant Daily: intraday trailing on peak balance/equity. Locks at the initial balance when reached or at the first payout, whichever comes first; never resets. Withdrawing down to the initial balance breaches the account.

Current CFD programs use two systems:

  • Dynamic Risk Shield™: 6% on Ash and Thunderbolt, 10% on Phoenix Legacy, 8% on Vanguard, 5% on Oracle and 4% on Ember. It trails the equity high-water mark and locks at the initial balance where specified.
  • Static maximum loss: 6% on Phoenix Classic. The floor is fixed from the initial balance.
    Percentages and behavior are shown per phase in the challenge catalogue.
  • Horizon and Odyssey: Dynamic Risk Shield™ follows the highest equity, only moves upward and stops at the initial balance, in evaluation and funded phases.
Profit Split

Profit split varies by product; see challenges. Add-ons may offer a higher split.

  • Instant Daily: base split in the catalogue; 70% on payouts 3 and 4, 80% from payout 5.

80% base profit split. At checkout, 90% is the default option and 100% is also available; both raise the Challenge price. Horizon and Odyssey have a fixed 80% split. The selected split remains linked to that account, and older accounts retain their original conditions.

Free Trial
No
Yes
Daily Drawdown

Most models: highest balance or equity recorded at end of day (EOD high-watermark).

  • Instant HERO: daily starting balance at 5 PM EST.
  • Instant Daily: none.

Resets daily at 00:00 UTC and is calculated under the rules of each program. Current limits:

  • Ash Classic/Turbo and Thunderbolt Classic/Turbo: 3%
  • Phoenix Classic: 4%
  • Phoenix Legacy: 5%
  • Vanguard and Oracle: 4%
  • Ember: no daily drawdown
  • Horizon: 3% and Odyssey: 4%, in evaluation and funded.
Three Steps
Yes
Yes
Max Allocation

$400,000 on every country except Pakistan, where the maximum is $50,000

1,500,000
Merge Accounts
Limited

Merging available on eligible accounts. Instant Daily cannot merge with any account.

No
Maximum Trading Days

Other models: unlimited. Instant Daily: account closes automatically after 30 days.

Classic and Legacy challenges have no time limit. Ash Turbo and Thunderbolt Turbo have 30 calendar days and a maximum of 7 trading days.

Minimum Trading Days

Instant HERO: 6 non-consecutive valid trading days before payout, with at least 0.5% profit each.

  • Instant Daily: none.

No minimum trading days to pass the challenge in any Classic or Turbo program. Turbo challenges require only 1 trading day with real activity. For those programs, minimums apply only at the payout stage: see 'minimumProfitableDays'.
Horizon requires 2 valid trading days in its evaluation. Odyssey requires 2 valid trading days in each evaluation phase. A valid day earns at least 0.5% of the initial balance.

Points Reward Program

The GOAT Points Program rewards traders for both purchases and trading activities:

  • You earn 1 point for every $1 spent and can gain additional points by completing trading tasks.
  • Points are credited instantly and can be tracked in your Trader Dashboard. You can redeem them for valuable perks such as free accounts, extra leverage, increased drawdown, and account size boosts.
  • There's no limit to how many points you can earn, and all GFT traders are automatically enrolled.
No data
Monthly Competition
No
No
Minimum Profitable Days
  • 3 days with 0.5% profit on all phases of evaluation accounts
  • 5 days with 0.5% profit on Instant Funding accounts other than Instant Daily
  • Instant Premium: 5 days with 0.5% profit (not necessarily consecutive)
  • Instant Daily: no minimum profitable days.

Payout eligibility requirements (a valid day has at least 0.5% realized profit):

  • Vanguard, Oracle, Ember, Phoenix Legacy, Ash Turbo and Thunderbolt Turbo: 5 valid days
  • Ash Classic, Thunderbolt Classic and Phoenix Classic: no valid-day minimum
    The counter resets after each successful payout.
    Horizon funded accounts require per payout 3 valid days up to $50,000, 4 above $50,000 and below $200,000, and 5 from $200,000. Odyssey funded accounts require 3 below $100,000 and 4 from $100,000. Each valid day earns at least 0.5% of the initial balance.
Expert Advisor (EA)
Yes
Yes

Allowed, including third-party EAs, bots and trade or risk managers, as long as the trading rules are followed. HFT, tick scalping, latency arbitrage, emulators and running the same EA with the same settings as other traders are prohibited.

VPN
No
Limited

Not explicitly prohibited, but strongly discouraged. Use of VPN/VPS during KYC/AML verification is prohibited and can result in the account not being funded or being closed. If suspicious activity is detected, VPN usage will be used against the trader in the review.

Hedging
No
No

Prohibited, also within the same account and across multiple accounts.

Requires Stop Loss
No
No
Scalping
Yes

Funded accounts only: minimum holding time of 1 minute for purchases from 6 October 2026 at 00:00 UTC; 2 minutes for earlier purchases, including their resets. Funded accounts follow the original challenge purchase date. Profits from shorter trades are excluded from payouts; losses still count. This is not an account breach. Evaluation accounts are exempt.

Yes
Stacking / Layering (DCA)
Yes
Yes

Multiple challenges and funded accounts combinable under a single user profile, as long as total funded capital does not exceed $1,500,000 across all Upcomers programs.

Maximum Risk Limit
Yes
  • Instant HERO: 1% maximum floating loss; breach closes the account.
  • The firm may impose a 1% risk-per-trade-idea limit after excessive risk-taking.
  • Instant Daily: combined floating loss across all open positions must stay below 1% of the initial balance; touching the limit closes the account.
Yes

Maximum loss per trade in the funded phase (all positions on the same instrument and direction count as one trade):

  • Ash Classic, Thunderbolt Classic and Phoenix Classic: 3%
  • Phoenix Legacy, Odyssey, Vanguard and Oracle: 2%
  • Ash Turbo, Thunderbolt Turbo, Horizon and Ember: 1.5%
    Exceeding the applicable limit is a hard breach.
Copy Trading
Limited

Allowed between your own GFT accounts only through Goat Copier, GFT's own trade copier: funded to funded, challenge to challenge, and challenge to funded in either direction. Applies to existing and new accounts. Any other trade copier or third-party tool is prohibited, as is copying other traders, or copying between GFT and personal broker accounts or accounts at another prop firm.

Limited

Only between accounts owned by the same person (Upcomers, other prop firms or brokers). Copying to or from other people's accounts and signal services are prohibited.

News Trading
Limited

Trades opened or closed (manually or by stop loss, take profit or pending orders) within 5 minutes before or after a high-impact news release (red folder on ForexFactory.com or Myfxbook.com) have a maximum profit per trade: 3% of the initial balance on accounts purchased from 10 November 2026, and 1% on accounts purchased earlier. Funded accounts and resets follow the original challenge purchase date. Applies to challenge and funded accounts; only profit above the cap is removed and it is not a breach.

Yes
Inactivity Rule

30 Days

35 consecutive calendar days without a trade closes the account automatically. Warning email sent 7 days before expiration.

Consistency Rule
Limited
  • Instant Goat: A single day cannot represent more than 15% of your total earnings when requesting a withdrawal.
  • Instant Premium: no consistency rule.
  • Instant HERO: no single day can represent 15% or more of total profits during a payout period.
  • Instant Daily: no daily profit consistency requirement. For payouts, the largest winning trade must be at least the largest losing trade, net of commission/swap; checked since purchase or the last payout. Partial closes count separately.
Limited

Consistency is checked at payout and does not breach the account:

  • 20% Best Day Rule: current Classic, Legacy and Turbo challenges, Vanguard, Oracle and Ember
    The Best Day cycle resets after each successful payout.
  • Horizon and Odyssey: no consistency or Best Day Rule in evaluation or funded accounts.
Hold Weekend
Yes
Yes
Prohibited Strategies
  • All or nothing
  • Exploit broker/platform errors
  • Use insider/non-public info
  • Front-run other trades
  • Excessively risky strategies
  • Hedging across accounts
  • Third-party EAs/strategies
  • Switch strategies post-assessment
  • Martingale/grid strategies banned
  • Emulators, and running the same EA with the same settings as other traders to produce identical trades.
  • Tick scalping (trades held under 2 minutes on Oracle) and high-frequency trading (HFT).
  • Martingale, grid trading, one-sided bets, reverse trading and hedging (also within the same account).
  • News straddling (bracket orders placed around economic releases).
  • Signal services and copying trades from other people's accounts.
  • Team/group trading or executing identical trades across accounts to bypass the $1.5M cap.
  • Sharing passwords, account access or identity (KYC).
  • Exploiting platform bugs, delays or pricing errors.
  • Opening multiple user profiles (One Person, One Account policy).
  • Splitting trades intentionally to bypass the 20% Best Day Rule.
Free newsletter

Pick your firms. Get what matters.

  • Exclusive promotions, updated daily
  • Funded trading industry news
  • Full control: you choose which firms to follow

FreeNo spamOne-click unsubscribe

Community

Join the community

Join us on our mission to become the most influential family in funded trading.

  • trade-ideasTrading ideas from the community
  • giveawaysGiveaways from prop firms
  • respect-leaderboardTop 10 by Respect earned
  • wins-and-lossesFundings, payouts and blown accounts
Join the Discord