/
Login
Breaking
All news
Comparison · Perps

Risk rules compared: Klein Funding vs Upcomers Perpetuals

Updated on

How you lose the account

At Klein Funding, the most immediate risk of account loss, beyond drawdown, is technical. On the Bybit platform, trading anything other than USDT Perpetuals (such as Spot, USDC, or Margin) results in an immediate breach. Additionally, deleting or changing the API connection on Bybit or requesting demo funds directly from the broker after connecting the API causes an irreversible loss of the account.

Upcomers Perpetuals focuses the risk of loss on strategy and inactivity. An account is forfeited after 35 consecutive days without closing a trade. Unlike Klein, Upcomers also enforces a maximum risk per trade; exceeding a 2% loss on a single trade (or 1.5% on Vanguard accounts) constitutes a rule violation. Furthermore, while Klein allows VPNs, Upcomers strongly discourages them and strictly prohibits their use during KYC/AML verification, which could lead to account complications.

Maximum drawdown

Klein Funding offers three distinct drawdown structures depending on the chosen plan:

  • Bybit Challenges: Static drawdown calculated from the initial balance. For a $100,000 account with a 6% limit, the account is lost if the equity touches $94,000, regardless of how much profit has been made.
  • Instant Pro: Features a "Smart Drawdown" (6%) that trails equity until the account reaches +3% profit, at which point it locks at -3% of the starting balance.
  • Cleo Challenges: Static drawdown between 3% and 8%.

Upcomers Perpetuals uses a mix of trailing and fixed models:

  • Thunderbolt/Vanguard: Trailing drawdown (6% and 7% respectively). In a $100,000 Thunderbolt account, if your equity rises to $102,000, your loss limit rises to $95,880. However, the Thunderbolt "Dynamic Risk Shield" locks at the initial balance ($100,000) once reached.
  • Phoenix: A fixed maximum drawdown of 6% based on the initial balance.

Daily drawdown

At Klein Funding, the daily loss limit for Bybit challenges is exactly half of the total loss limit. It is calculated based on the starting balance at 12:05 AM UTC.

  • Example: If you have a $50,000 account with a 6% total drawdown ($3,000), your daily limit is 3% ($1,500). If you start the day at $51,000, you lose the account if your equity drops to $49,500 that same day.

Upcomers Perpetuals applies a fixed percentage based on the program: 3% for Thunderbolt and Vanguard, and 3.5% for Phoenix. The reset occurs at 00:00 UTC.

  • Example: On a $50,000 Phoenix account, the daily limit is 3.5% ($1,750). If you start the day at $50,000, you cannot drop below $48,250. If you have grown the account to $52,000, the 3.5% is still calculated from the balance at the start of the day ($52,000), meaning you could lose the account at $50,180.

Rules beyond drawdown

Klein Funding imposes a "Stability Score" on Bybit challenges. No single trading day can account for more than 30% (One Step) or 45% (Two Step) of your total profit. While this does not breach the account, it prevents withdrawal until the ratio is diluted through further trading. Klein also requires trades to be held for at least 50 seconds.

Upcomers Perpetuals is more restrictive regarding trade duration and consistency. It enforces a "20% Best Day Rule" for all payouts. Moreover, it explicitly prohibits hedging between accounts and limits the risk per trade. While Klein does not mention a maximum loss per trade, Upcomers will fail an account if a single trade's risk exceeds the 1.5% - 2% threshold. Upcomers also considers trades closed in under two minutes as potential "tick scalping," a much tighter window than Klein's 50 seconds.

Risk that comes from the setup

The execution environment differs significantly. Klein Funding utilizes Bybit and its proprietary Cleo platform (Binance data). The risk here is the "Stability Rule" and API management on Bybit. The asset class is strictly limited to Crypto.

Upcomers Perpetuals uses the Hyperliquid live order book. This provides a decentralized finance (DeFi) execution environment which might offer different slippage profiles compared to centralized exchanges. Unlike Klein, Upcomers allows trading in Forex, Stocks, ETFs, and Indices through perpetual contracts. This allows for diversification but introduces the risk of "Hourly Funding" rates, which settle every hour and directly affect equity and drawdown calculations—a risk factor absent in Klein's traditional crypto fee structure.

What is at stake and what you recover

Klein Funding does not offer refunds for challenge fees. However, it provides a very fast payout processing time (4-24 hours). Payout methods include Bank Transfer, Wise, and Crypto (USDT, BTC, ETH).

Upcomers Perpetuals offers a 200% refund of the entry fee, but only after the third fully approved payout, and it excludes Vanguard accounts. Payouts are on-demand, but Upcomers charges significant fees: up to 30% for cryptocurrency withdrawals and a $19.90 flat fee. There is also a progressive payout cap ladder that limits how much you can withdraw until your 8th payout.

The "cost of failure" is higher at Upcomers for similar account sizes. For example, a $100,000 One Step challenge at Klein costs $1,035.50, while a $100,000 Thunderbolt at Upcomers costs $1,159.

Frequently asked questions

Which firm is more affordable for a $10,000 evaluation, Klein Funding or Upcomers Perpetuals?

Klein Funding is significantly more affordable for this size. A $10,000 "One Step Bybit" account at Klein costs $137.75, whereas a $10,000 "Thunderbolt Classic" (one-step) at Upcomers Perpetuals costs $239. Even Klein's "Two Step" $10,000 account is cheaper at $114.

Which firm has a stricter consistency rule for withdrawals, Klein Funding or Upcomers Perpetuals?

Upcomers Perpetuals is stricter regarding the "Best Day" rule, as it limits any single day to 20% of the total profit required for withdrawal. Klein Funding allows more breathing room with a 30% threshold for its One Step challenges and 45% for Two Step challenges under its Stability Score rule.

Can I trade more assets at Klein Funding or Upcomers Perpetuals?

Upcomers Perpetuals offers a much wider range of assets, including approximately 130 markets covering Crypto, Forex, Stocks, ETFs, Indices, and Commodities. Klein Funding is strictly limited to Cryptocurrency trading, and specifically to USDT Perpetuals when using the Bybit platform.

Which firm processes payouts faster, Klein Funding or Upcomers Perpetuals?

Klein Funding provides a faster and more predictable payout experience, with most withdrawals processed within 4 to 24 hours (often under 4 hours) via Bank Transfer, Wise, or Crypto. Upcomers Perpetuals offers on-demand payouts, but they are subject to heavy fees (up to 30% for crypto) and a progressive cap system that limits withdrawal amounts during the first seven payouts.

Field by field

Klein Funding and Upcomers Perpetuals, side by side

Rules, plans, platforms, leverage, commissions and payouts of both, with the option to see only what differs.

Head to head

48 differences

15%off · Exclusive
90%off · Exclusive
Headquarters

Tbilisi, Samgori District, Besarion Chichinadze Street 12, Apartment No. 55, Georgia

Building A1, IFZA Business Park, Dubai Silicon Oasis, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

CEO

Kutay Aktaş

Jakub Zeliska

Country

Georgia

United Arab Emirates

Foundation

2024

2023

Banned Countries
No data
Afghanistan, Central African Republic, Crimea, Donetsk and Luhansk regions of Ukraine, Cuba, Iran, Iraq, Kosovo, Libya, Mali, Myanmar, North Korea, Palestine, Russia, Somalia, South Sudan, Sudan, Syria, Vanuatu, Venezuela
Assets
Crypto
Crypto, Stocks, ETFs, Indices, Commodities, Forex
Brokers
Bybit, Cleo (Binance data)

Live Hyperliquid order book and market data

Refund
No
Yes

Challenge accounts qualify for a bonus equal to 200% of the entry fee after the third fully approved payout. It does not apply to instant funding accounts (Vanguard and Oracle).

Payout Fee
No data

Bank transfer: $19.90 + 2.49%. Cryptocurrency: $19.90 + 30%. Returned payouts: $30 reprocessing fee.

Platforms
ByBit, Cleo Trading Platform
Upcomers
Payout Methods
Transfer, Wise, Crypto
Crypto, Transfer
Payment Methods
Card, Crypto
Card, Crypto, PayPal, ApplePay, GooglePay
Payout Frequency

Bybit Instant Pro & Cleo challenges: Daily on-demand withdrawals. Payouts processed in 4-24 hours (usually within 4 hours).

Bybit One Step & Two Step: Every 3-4 days due to Stability Rule.

Thunderbolt, Phoenix, Vanguard and Oracle: on demand when all requirements are met. Horizon and Odyssey: every 14 days. Qualifying days with at least 0.5% realized profit before each payout: Vanguard 5 (6 on accounts bought before 26 October 2026), Oracle 5, Horizon 3 to 5 and Odyssey 3 or 4 by size; Thunderbolt and Phoenix none. The counter resets after every payout.

Payout Guarantee

4-24 hours (usually within 4 hours)

No data
Crypto Weekend Trading
Yes
Yes
Maximum Withdrawal
No data

Perpetuals use the same progressive payout-cap ladder as CFD accounts. The cap increases with each fully approved payout and is removed from payout #8 onward. Profit above the applicable cap is forfeited at the end of the segment.

Minimum Withdrawal
No data

$45 after applying the selected profit split.

Other Payout Requirements
No data

At least 1% realized profit (3% on Horizon and Odyssey) since account start or the previous payout; all positions closed; drawdown compliance; completed KYC and signed Trader Agreement.

Crypto

Bybit challenges (One Step, Two Step, Instant Pro): Up to 1:100 for most tradeable coins on Bybit.

Cleo challenges (One Step, Flex): BTC and ETH up to 1:5, all other assets up to 1:2.

BTC, ETH and SOL: up to 10:1. Other cryptocurrencies: up to 2:1

Forex
No data

Forex perpetuals: up to 25:1

Metals
No data

Gold and silver: up to 8:1. Copper: up to 5:1

Energies
No data

WTI and Brent crude: up to 8:1

Indices
No data

Index perpetuals: up to 10:1

Stocks
No data

Stock and ETF perpetuals: up to 4:1

Crypto
0
No data
Commission-Free Option
No
No data
Commission
No data

Crypto perpetuals: 0.015% maker / 0.045% taker. Stocks, ETFs, indices, commodities and forex: 0.003% maker / 0.009% taker. MSTR, PURRDAT and GOLD: 0.03% maker / 0.09% taker. No spread markup; $10 minimum order.

Swap Free
Yes

Crypto markets are swap-free by nature.

No
Account Reset
No data

Resets may be offered after a rule violation. A violation-related reset permanently caps future payouts on that account at 50% of the approved amount.

Add-ons
Yes
No
Instant
Yes
Yes
One Step
Yes
Yes
Account scaling
Yes

Instant Pro only: make 10% profit on account balance, forfeit 50% of your profit share, and your account size doubles. Scaling up to $2M.

Yes

Eligible funded accounts can scale by 35% every four consecutive months, up to $4,000,000, after achieving 15% cumulative growth, at least two payouts and a profitable final cycle.

Two Steps
Yes
Yes
Max Drawdown

Bybit challenges (One Step, Two Step)
Static drawdown calculated from initial balance. Customizable from 6% to 10%.

Bybit Instant Pro
Two drawdown types available (3-8%):

  • Smart Drawdown (6%): Trails upward with equity gains. Once account reaches +3% profit, drawdown locks permanently at -3% of starting balance.
  • Trailing Drawdown (8%): Trails the High Water Mark (highest of balance or equity). After first payout, resets to 4% trailing from the new balance.

Cleo challenges (One Step, Flex)
Static drawdown calculated from initial balance. Customizable from 3% to 8%. One Step: 5% default. Flex: 3% default.

Thunderbolt, Horizon and Odyssey: 6% trailing Dynamic Risk Shield that locks at the starting balance. Phoenix: 6% fixed maximum drawdown. Vanguard: 8% trailing maximum drawdown (7% on accounts bought before 2 November 2026). Oracle: 5% trailing maximum drawdown.

Profit Split

Bybit challenges (One Step, Two Step, Instant Pro): Customizable from 60% to 90% depending on the plan selected.

Cleo challenges (One Step, Flex): Customizable from 60% to 90% depending on the plan selected.

Thunderbolt, Phoenix, Vanguard and Oracle: 80% base split; 90% (checkout default) or 100% can be chosen for a higher price. Horizon and Odyssey: fixed 80%.

Free Trial
No
No
Daily Drawdown

Bybit challenges: Daily maximum loss is half of the total loss limit. Calculated from starting balance at 12:05 AM UTC and does not change during the day until next daily reset.

Cleo challenges: Daily drawdown varies by selected plan and configuration (3-4%).

Thunderbolt and Horizon: 3%. Phoenix, Vanguard, Oracle and Odyssey: 4%. Measured from the higher of equity or balance at 00:00 UTC.

Three Steps
No
No data
Max Allocation
300,000

Current Perpetuals accounts are sold up to $400,000. Total funded capital across all Upcomers programs cannot exceed $1,500,000. Eligible accounts can scale to $4,000,000.

Merge Accounts
No
No
Maximum Trading Days

No time limit. Trade at your own pace.

Unlimited.

Minimum Trading Days

Bybit challenges (One Step, Two Step): 3-4 minimum trading days due to Stability Rule.

Bybit Instant Pro: 3 trading days with at least 0.5% profit each (for payout eligibility).

Cleo challenges (One Step, Flex): No minimum trading days required. Pass the challenge at your own pace.

Thunderbolt and Phoenix: no minimum to pass. Horizon: 2 days. Odyssey: 2 days per phase. Vanguard has no evaluation.

Minimum Profitable Days
No data

Before each payout, days with at least 0.5% realized profit: Vanguard 5 (6 on accounts bought before 26 October 2026); Oracle 5; Horizon 3 up to $50K, 4 up to $200K and 5 from $200K; Odyssey 3 below $100K and 4 from $100K. Thunderbolt and Phoenix: none.

Expert Advisor (EA)
No
No
VPN
Yes
Limited

Not explicitly prohibited, but strongly discouraged. VPN or VPS use during KYC/AML verification is prohibited.

Hedging
Yes
No

Prohibited, even within a single account, and across accounts.

Requires Stop Loss
No
No
Scalping
Yes

All trades must be held for more than 50 seconds. Tick scalping is prohibited.

Limited

Normal scalping is allowed. Tick scalping, HFT and latency exploitation are prohibited; trades repeatedly closed in under two minutes may be treated as tick scalping.

Stacking / Layering (DCA)
Yes
Yes
Martingale
No data
No
Maximum Risk Limit
No
Yes

Funded maximum loss per trade: 3% on Thunderbolt and Phoenix; 2% on Vanguard, Oracle and Odyssey; 1.5% on Horizon. Positions on the same instrument and direction count as one trade. Exceeding it is a hard breach.

Copy Trading
No
No
News Trading
Yes
Yes
Inactivity Rule

Bybit API access period is 90 days. Reminder emails are sent starting 10 days before expiration. If not renewed within that period, the account will be restricted and cannot be reactivated.

Yes

The account expires after 35 consecutive days without closing a trade. A warning is sent 7 days before expiration.

Consistency Rule
Yes

Stability Score (Bybit challenges only): No single trading day's profit can be equal to or greater than the stability threshold of total profits.

  • Bybit Two Step: 45% stability score
  • Bybit One Step: 30% stability score
  • Bybit Instant Pro: No stability score

Cleo challenges (One Step, Flex): No Stability Rule.

Violating the rule does not breach the account. The trader must continue trading until the best day's profit falls below the threshold.

Yes

20% Best Day Rule at payout for Thunderbolt, Phoenix, Vanguard and Oracle. It is a soft payout requirement and does not breach the account. Horizon and Odyssey: no consistency rule.

Hold Weekend
Yes
Yes

All Perpetuals markets trade 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

Prohibited Strategies
  • Arbitrage trading
  • Latency trading
  • High-frequency trading (HFT)
  • Hedging between accounts
  • Tick scalping
  • Holding trades less than 50 seconds
  • Spamming the order book
  • Group trading
  • Exploiting the demo environment
  • Expert Advisors (EAs) and automated trading systems
  • Copy trading (even between own accounts)
  • Front-running price feeds
  • Exploiting unrealistic prices or mispricing

Platform or feed exploitation, tick scalping, high-frequency trading, latency trading, arbitrage, grid trading, martingale, one-sided or all-or-nothing bets, reverse or group hedging, external signal or challenge-passing services, account sharing and coordinated trading are prohibited.

Overnight positions
No data
Yes
Free newsletter

Pick your firms. Get what matters.

  • Exclusive promotions, updated daily
  • Funded trading industry news
  • Full control: you choose which firms to follow

FreeNo spamOne-click unsubscribe

Community

Join the community

Join us on our mission to become the most influential family in funded trading.

  • trade-ideasTrading ideas from the community
  • giveawaysGiveaways from prop firms
  • respect-leaderboardTop 10 by Respect earned
  • wins-and-lossesFundings, payouts and blown accounts
Join the Discord