Day one
The entry experience differs significantly in both cost and technology. Halcyon Trader Funding provides a wide array of industry-standard platforms (TradingView, ATAS, Quantower) via Rithmic or Ironbeam. ForTraders Futures requires the use of their proprietary platform, For Traders X.
- Halcyon Entry: Offers "Dynamic" evaluations starting at $47 for 50K, or "Lite/Prime" models where you choose between a lower upfront cost plus an activation fee, or a higher "all-in" price. The 150K Lite evaluation costs $138 (plus a $163 activation fee later).
- forTraders Entry: Offers "Fast" evaluations (50K for $199) or "Instant" funding where you skip the evaluation entirely (50K for $399). There are no activation fees for the Fast models.
- Initial Rules: Halcyon prohibits weekend and overnight holding, requiring all positions to be closed by 4:45 PM EST. forTraders allows weekend holding without restrictions. Both firms have a 40% consistency rule on their standard evaluation paths (Prime for Halcyon, Fast for forTraders).
The first months
Once the evaluation is passed, the focus shifts to payout consistency and risk management.
- Payout Requirements:
- Halcyon: Requires 6 qualifying trading days before each request. Each day must meet a minimum profit (e.g., $200 for a 50K account). There is no "buffer" required for accounts purchased after August 2026; you only need to be above the starting balance.
- forTraders: Requires 5 profitable days for "Fast" accounts and 7 for "Instant" accounts. A minimum 5-second hold time is required for scalping.
- Profit Sharing: Halcyon offers a superior 90/10 split from the start. forTraders starts with an 80/20 split.
- Risk Limits: Halcyon uses intraday trailing drawdown for Lite and end-of-day for Prime. forTraders uses trailing drawdown for Fast and a 5% EOD trailing for Instant. Notably, Halcyon has no daily loss limit, whereas some forTraders models (Fast Pro/Instant) do include daily limits.
The first year
This is where the scaling and professional paths diverge. Halcyon moves toward institutional-style trading, while forTraders rewards consistent performance with fixed benefits.
- Halcyon's Professional Path: After 5 approved rewards, accounts are reviewed for the "Trader Live Training" (TLT) program. This is a bridge to a "Live Brokerage" account on Ironbeam. In the live account, the profit split becomes 100% for the trader, and daily payouts are available.
- forTraders' Premium Program: Scaling is managed through a Loyalty Program (XP-based) and a three-tier Premium Program:
- Bronze (4 months): 25% balance boost.
- Silver (8 months): $750 monthly salary and 50% balance boost.
- Gold (12 months): $1,500 monthly salary and 75% balance boost.
The ceiling
The maximum potential for a trader depends on how many accounts they can manage and the absolute capital limits.
- Halcyon Limits:
- Maximum of 3 active Reward accounts at any time.
- Maximum account size is $150,000.
- However, Live Brokerage accounts can reach up to 3X the size of the previous transition model, effectively raising the ceiling for proven traders.
- forTraders Limits:
- Maximum virtual capital allocation of $300,000 combined across all accounts.
- Scaling is unlocked through the 5-tier Loyalty Program (Starter to Legend), which improves profit shares and drawdown allowances.
- No account merging is available for either firm.
Room to grow
Halcyon Trader Funding is designed for the trader who eventually wants to leave the "simulated" world and trade in a real brokerage (Ironbeam) with a 100% profit split. Its growth is vertical: from simulation to live markets.
forTraders Futures is built for the "prop-firm" specialist who values extra perks like monthly salaries and XP-based rewards. Its growth is horizontal: increasing the virtual balance and adding fixed income (salaries) to the profit split. Halcyon offers better technology and a higher initial profit split (90% vs 80%), while forTraders offers more flexibility with weekend holding and the unique "Instant" funding option.
Frequently asked questions
Which firm is cheaper to start a 50K evaluation, Halcyon or forTraders?
Halcyon is significantly cheaper for the initial evaluation phase. A Halcyon Dynamic 50K evaluation costs between $47 and $49, whereas a forTraders Fast 50K evaluation costs $199. However, keep in mind that Halcyon requires an upgrade/activation fee after passing, while forTraders' Fast evaluation price is all-inclusive.
Does Halcyon or forTraders offer a higher profit split for funded traders?
Halcyon offers a higher profit split, starting at 90% for all Lite, Prime, and Dynamic accounts, and reaching 100% if the trader transitions to a Live Brokerage account. forTraders starts at 80% for all its futures products, though this can be improved through their Loyalty Program tiers.
Can I hold positions over the weekend in Halcyon or forTraders?
You can only hold positions over the weekend in forTraders, which allows weekend holding without restrictions. Halcyon is strictly a day-trading firm; all positions must be closed daily by 4:45 PM EST, and failure to do so can result in account liquidation.
Which firm allows the use of EAs and automated bots, Halcyon or forTraders?
Halcyon has more permissive rules for automation, allowing bots and algos as long as the trader is the sole owner and they are not HFT systems. forTraders strictly prohibits fully autonomous bots, only allowing EAs as "decision-support tools" for alerts or partial trade management.






















