/
Login
Breaking
All news
Comparison · Forex

Detailed Comparison: QT Funded vs Upcomers (2025)

Updated on

1. Business Foundation and Transparency

Both firms were established in 2023, positioning them as relatively new players in the industry. However, their operational bases and transparency levels differ:

  • QT Funded operates from South Africa and maintains a high level of public trust with a Trustpilot score of 4.5 and over 12,000 reviews, indicating a large, active user base.
  • Upcomers is based in the United Arab Emirates (Dubai). Notably, its Trustpilot is currently blocked, which is a significant red flag for traders seeking verified external feedback, although they do report approximately 450 reviews.
  • Geographic Restrictions: Upcomers has a much more extensive list of banned countries, including the UAE itself, whereas QT Funded focuses its restrictions on high-risk jurisdictions like North Korea, Russia, and Syria.

2. Allocation Limits and Scalability

For traders looking to manage significant capital, the difference in "ceiling" is substantial:

  • QT Funded: Offers a total max allocation of $400,000. While they allow account merging, no single merged account can exceed $200,000. This makes it a firm more suited for mid-tier retail traders.
  • Upcomers: Provides a much higher capital ceiling with a total funded limit of $1,500,000. Furthermore, their scaling plan is aggressive, allowing traders to reach up to $4,000,000 through 35% balance increases every 4 months.
  • Consequence: Upcomers is clearly designed for "pro" traders or those aiming for institutional-sized simulation accounts, while QT Funded keeps a more conservative risk profile regarding total exposure per trader.

3. Evaluation Models and Program Variety

Upcomers offers a vastly more complex ecosystem of programs compared to QT Funded’s structured approach:

  • QT Funded Programs: Focuses on 1, 2, and 3-step evaluations, plus an "Instant" model. Their structures are traditional, with profit targets ranging from 5% to 8% depending on the phase.
  • Upcomers Programs: Features a high variety of specialized paths:
    • Classic/Turbo: From 1/2-step to 5-step evaluations (Eon).
    • Legacy: Programs with Static Drawdown instead of trailing.
    • High-Speed Sessions: Supernova (24h) and Hypernova (4h) sessions for traders who want to get funded or fail in a single day.
  • Risk Note: Upcomers' 4h/24h programs are extremely high-risk "gamified" models that require 7 trades in a very short window, favoring high-frequency styles that are banned in their other programs.

4. Drawdown Mechanics: Trailing vs. Static

Understanding how these firms calculate failure is critical for account longevity:

  • QT Funded: Uses Balance-based daily drawdown. For their Prime and Power accounts, the maximum drawdown is Static, meaning it stays fixed at the starting level. However, their Instant accounts use a Trailing drawdown, which is more restrictive as the floor moves up with your profits.
  • Upcomers: Implements a tiered drawdown system.
    • Static Drawdown: Used in evaluation phases, which is safer for the trader.
    • Dynamic Risk Shield™: A trailing drawdown that follows equity (High-Water Mark) but locks permanently at the starting balance once the profit target is hit. This is a unique hybrid that protects the firm during growth but offers security to the trader once the account is established.

5. Payout Structure and Hidden Costs

While both firms offer high profit splits, the "fine print" on withdrawals is where they diverge most:

  • Profit Split: QT Funded offers 80% to 100% (on Prime On Demand). Upcomers offers a nearly industry-leading 99% split, but this comes with significant friction.
  • Withdrawal Caps (Upcomers): New funded traders at Upcomers face a progressive cap. Your first withdrawal is limited to only 1% of the initial balance, scaling slowly up to the 7th withdrawal. You only get unlimited payouts from the 8th withdrawal onwards.
  • Withdrawal Fees: QT Funded has a standard $100 minimum. Upcomers charges significant fees: $19.90 + 2.49% for bank transfers and a staggering $19.90 + 30% for Crypto due to UAE liquidity issues.
  • Consequence: While 99% profit split sounds superior, the progressive caps and high transaction fees at Upcomers mean that a QT Funded trader might actually pocket more liquid cash in their first few months of consistency.

6. Trading Rules and Strategy Restrictions

  • Expert Advisors (EAs): QT Funded allows EAs but requires a pre-approval process. Upcomers strictly prohibits all EAs, bots, and automation, including partial management of entries or exits.
  • News Trading: Upcomers allows news trading. QT Funded has a 5-minute "no-trade" window before and after high-impact news (except for their Prime On Demand accounts).
  • Risk Limits: Both have "Hard Breach" rules for risk. QT Funded requires a Stop Loss within 60 seconds of opening a trade. Upcomers has a Max Single Trade Loss (e.g., 3% for Classic accounts), which if exceeded, results in immediate account closure.
  • Consistency: Both use consistency rules. QT Funded sets a 35% ceiling for a single day's profit, whereas Upcomers is stricter at 20% (Best Day Rule) for most accounts.

7. Summary: Which Firm to Choose?

Choose QT Funded if:

  • You prioritize verified reputation and transparent Trustpilot feedback.
  • You use Expert Advisors (with approval) or require a simple, standard withdrawal process without progressive caps.
  • You prefer a firm with a local broker (Quant Tekel) and more traditional, predictable rules.
  • You are a retail trader focusing on accounts between $10,000 and $200,000.

Choose Upcomers if:

  • You are an extremely high-volume or professional trader aiming for the $1.5M - $4M allocation range.
  • You trade manually and do not use any form of automation.
  • You want the 99% profit split and are willing to wait through 7 withdrawals to unlock unlimited payout capacity.
  • You are interested in Static Drawdown evaluation phases or "Speed-funding" sessions (24h/4h) and understand the high risks involved.
  • You are comfortable with high withdrawal fees in exchange for higher theoretical profit shares.
Field by field

QT Funded and Upcomers, side by side

Rules, plans, platforms, leverage, commissions and payouts of both, with the option to see only what differs.

Head to head

55 differences

90%off · Exclusive
Headquarters

Cape Town, South Africa, Western Cape, 7764, ZA

Building A1, IFZA Business Park, Dubai Silicon Oasis, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

CEO

Tanswell Sassman

Jakub Zeliska

Country

South Africa

United Arab Emirates

Foundation

2023

2023

Banned Countries
Cyprus, Iran, North Korea (Democratic People's Republic of Korea), Sudan, Syria, Russia
Afghanistan, Central African Republic, Crimea, Donetsk and Luhansk regions of Ukraine, Cuba, Iran, Iraq, Kosovo, Libya, Mali, Myanmar, North Korea, Palestine, Russia, Somalia, South Sudan, Sudan, Syria, Vanuatu, Venezuela
Assets
Forex, Commodities, Indices, Crypto
Forex, Commodities, Indices, Stocks, Crypto
Brokers
Quant Tekel
Royal Flow - FZCO
Refund
Yes

Only when purchasing with add-on

Yes

200% Challenge fee refund after the 3rd fully approved payout on Challenge accounts (Ash, Thunderbolt and Phoenix). The trader must request it through support. A partially approved payout or a payout with a strategy violation permanently disqualifies that account. It does not apply to Instant Funding accounts.

Platforms
Metatrader 5, cTrader, TradeLocker
TradeLocker, Metatrader 5, MatchTrader, cTrader, DX
Demo Account
Metatrader 5
ID10255137Password6M!3h%PzFrServerQuantTekel-Server
TradeLocker
IDspreads@qtfunded.comPassword5Tagx>J}SnpKServerQTEKEL
Metatrader 5
ID1293766PasswordUpcomers1.ServerUpcomers-Server
Payout Methods
Crypto, Transfer, Card
Crypto, Transfer
Payment Methods
Crypto, Transfer, Card, PayPal
Card, Crypto, PayPal, ApplePay, GooglePay
Payout Frequency
  • QT ONE: 4-day cycle
  • QT TWO: 14-day cycle
  • QT INSTANT: 4-day cycle
  • QT Power: 14-day cycle for accounts purchased from August 11, 2026. Accounts purchased on or before August 10 receive the first payout on demand, then move to a 14-day cycle.
  • QT 1 Step (BNPL): 14-day standard cycle
  • QT Bonus (promotional accounts): 30-day cycle
  • Withdrawal review by Risk Team: 24-48h (account trading is frozen during review).
  • Bank transfers: 2-5 business days after approval.
  • Crypto: faster, depends on blockchain network.
  • Other programs: minimum 1% profit required per payout (resets after each payout).
  • Turbo accounts: minimum 5 trading days per payout (each ≥0.5% profit).
  • Vanguard (Instant Funding): minimum 5 trading days per payout (each ≥0.5% profit).
  • Horizon and Odyssey: first payout 14 days after the funded account starts, then every 14 days. At least 3% profit of the initial balance is required before each payout, including between payouts, together with the required valid trading days.
Alternative Currency
GBP
No data
Minimum Withdrawal

1% of profit ($100 min) — except QT INSTANT: 5% of profit, and a 3% buffer applies (8% profit must be reached before the first payout request).

No data
Payout Fee
No data
  • Bank Transfer (recommended): $19.90 + 2.49%.
  • Cryptocurrency: $19.90 + 30% (higher due to limited UAE crypto liquidity).
  • Returned payouts: $30 reprocessing fee (covers real bank/admin cost of reprocessing; not a penalty).
Crypto Weekend Trading
No data
Yes
Maximum Withdrawal
No data

Payout cap progresses with each approved withdrawal on the same funded account:

  • Payout #1: 1% of initial balance
  • Payout #2: 2%
  • Payout #3: 3%
  • Payout #4: 4%
  • Payout #5: 5%
  • Payout #6: 6%
  • Payout #7: account resets to initial balance with NO payout cap (unlimited from #8 onwards)
    Cap only increases after a FULLY approved withdrawal. Partial or declined payouts do not progress the cap.
Forex
50:1
100:1
Metals
15:1
30:1
Energies
10:1
30:1
Indices
20:1
30:1
Crypto
1:1
30:1
Stocks
No data
30:1
Forex
4 / lot
5 / lot
Metals
4 / lot
5 / lot
Energies
4 / lot
0
Indices
4 / lot
0
Crypto
4 / lot
0.04%
Commission-Free Option
Yes
No
Stocks
No data
0
Swap Free
Yes
Yes

All accounts are swap‑free

Account Reset

Phase 2 reset available with add-on

Resets are offered as an alternative to full suspension after a rule violation. The account continues trading, but every future payout on that account is permanently capped at 50% of the approved amount.

Add-ons
Yes
  • Variable Spreads
  • Usage of EA
  • Swap Free
  • 10% Profit Split Extra (80% → 90%)
  • Refund on First Payout
  • 14 Day Payout cycle
  • 7 Day Payout cycle
No
Instant
Yes
Yes
One Step
Yes
Yes
Account scaling
Yes
Yes

Scaling Plan for Thunderbolt and Vanguard accounts:

  • Apply every 4 consecutive months via help@upcomers.com.
  • +35% increase on simulated initial balance per cycle.
  • Maximum allocation scalable up to $4,000,000.
    Requirements per cycle:
  • ≥15% cumulative account growth across the 4 months.
  • ≥2 withdrawals completed in the 4-month period.
  • Final cycle must end in profit.
    Separate "4M on request" individual contract available after 6+ consecutive profitable months.
Two Steps
Yes
Yes
Max Drawdown
  • QT ONE: 6% static
  • QT TWO: 8% static
  • QT INSTANT: 6% trailing, locked at starting balance once a withdrawal is made
  • QT Power: 8% static
  • QT 1 Step (BNPL): 6% trailing

Current CFD programs use two systems:

  • Dynamic Risk Shield™: 6% on Ash and Thunderbolt, 10% on Phoenix Legacy, 8% on Vanguard, 5% on Oracle and 4% on Ember. It trails the equity high-water mark and locks at the initial balance where specified.
  • Static maximum loss: 6% on Phoenix Classic. The floor is fixed from the initial balance.
    Percentages and behavior are shown per phase in the challenge catalogue.
  • Horizon and Odyssey: Dynamic Risk Shield™ follows the highest equity, only moves upward and stops at the initial balance, in evaluation and funded phases.
Profit Split
  • QT ONE: 70%
  • QT TWO: 80%
  • QT INSTANT: 100%
  • QT Power: 80%
  • QT 1 Step (BNPL): 80%
    Upgradeable to 90% with the "10% Profit Split Extra" add-on on eligible plans.

Standard profit split: 90%. A trader can select 80% or 100% at checkout; changing the split also changes the Challenge price. The selected split remains linked to that account, and older accounts retain their original conditions.

Free Trial
No
Yes
Daily Drawdown
  • QT ONE: 3% trailing (fixed amount, threshold recalculated daily on the higher of previous close balance or equity)
  • QT TWO: 4% fixed (balance-based)
  • QT INSTANT: 3% fixed
  • QT Power: 4% fixed
  • QT 1 Step (BNPL): 3% daily trailing

Resets daily at 00:00 UTC and is calculated under the rules of each program. Current limits:

  • Ash Classic/Turbo and Thunderbolt Classic/Turbo: 3%
  • Phoenix Classic: 4%
  • Phoenix Legacy: 5%
  • Vanguard and Oracle: 4%
  • Ember: no daily drawdown
  • Horizon: 3% and Odyssey: 4%, in evaluation and funded.
Three Steps
No
Yes
Max Allocation
  • Max total funded allocation: $300,000
  • Max Instant funded allocation: $100,000
  • No duplicate asset trading when at limit
1,500,000
Merge Accounts
Yes
No
Maximum Trading Days

Unlimited

Classic and Legacy challenges have no time limit. Ash Turbo and Thunderbolt Turbo have 30 calendar days and a maximum of 7 trading days.

Minimum Trading Days
  • QT ONE: no minimum on the evaluation (can pass in a single day); 4 days when funded
  • QT TWO: 4 days per phase
  • QT INSTANT: 4 days when funded
  • QT Power: 4 days in each evaluation phase and 4 days per funded payout cycle
  • QT 1 Step (BNPL): no minimum on the evaluation; 5 days when funded

No minimum trading days to pass the challenge in any Classic or Turbo program. Turbo challenges require only 1 trading day with real activity. For those programs, minimums apply only at the payout stage: see 'minimumProfitableDays'.
Horizon requires 2 valid trading days in its evaluation. Odyssey requires 2 valid trading days in each evaluation phase. A valid day earns at least 0.5% of the initial balance.

Monthly Competition
No
No
Minimum Profitable Days
  • QT TWO: 4 days of +0.5% profit per cycle
  • QT INSTANT: 4 days of +1% profit per cycle
  • QT ONE: not required

Payout eligibility requirements (a valid day has at least 0.5% realized profit):

  • Vanguard, Oracle, Ember, Phoenix Legacy, Ash Turbo and Thunderbolt Turbo: 5 valid days
  • Ash Classic, Thunderbolt Classic and Phoenix Classic: no valid-day minimum
    The counter resets after each successful payout.
    Horizon funded accounts require per payout 3 valid days up to $50,000, 4 above $50,000 and below $200,000, and 5 from $200,000. Odyssey funded accounts require 3 below $100,000 and 4 from $100,000. Each valid day earns at least 0.5% of the initial balance.
Expert Advisor (EA)
Limited

Before using EAs, they must go through a pre-approval process.

Yes

Allowed, including third-party EAs, bots and trade or risk managers, as long as the trading rules are followed. HFT, tick scalping, latency arbitrage, emulators and running the same EA with the same settings as other traders are prohibited.

VPN
Yes
Limited

Not explicitly prohibited, but strongly discouraged. Use of VPN/VPS during KYC/AML verification is prohibited and can result in the account not being funded or being closed. If suspicious activity is detected, VPN usage will be used against the trader in the review.

Hedging
Yes
No

Prohibited, also within the same account and across multiple accounts.

Requires Stop Loss
Yes

A Stop Loss must be placed within 60 seconds of opening a trade. Applies to QT TWO and QT INSTANT (funded accounts). QT ONE has no stop loss rule.

No
Scalping
Yes
Yes
Stacking / Layering (DCA)
No

Cannot have three or more open positions on the same asset at the same time (only funded account

Yes

Multiple challenges and funded accounts combinable under a single user profile, as long as total funded capital does not exceed $1,500,000 across all Upcomers programs.

Maximum Risk Limit
Yes
  • QT ONE (Funded): 1% max floating loss across all open positions
  • QT TWO (Funded): 1% max floating loss (first violation is a soft breach, second is a hard breach)
  • QT TWO (Evaluation): exposure must stay under 75% of the daily drawdown limit
  • QT INSTANT (Funded): 1% max exposure per instrument
  • QT Power (Evaluation): exposure must stay under 75% of the daily drawdown limit
  • QT Power (Funded): no exposure limit
  • QT 1 Step (BNPL, Funded): 2% floating loss
Yes

Maximum loss per trade in the funded phase (all positions on the same instrument and direction count as one trade):

  • Ash Classic, Thunderbolt Classic and Phoenix Classic: 3%
  • Phoenix Legacy, Odyssey, Vanguard and Oracle: 2%
  • Ash Turbo, Thunderbolt Turbo, Horizon and Ember: 1.5%
    Exceeding the applicable limit is a hard breach.
Copy Trading
Yes

Allowed without restrictions when allocation is lower than $300,000.
Not allowed when the allocation is $300,000 or above.

Limited

Only between accounts owned by the same person (Upcomers, other prop firms or brokers). Copying to or from other people's accounts and signal services are prohibited.

News Trading
Limited
  • No new entries or exits within the 10-minute window around a restricted news event (5 minutes before and 5 minutes after).
  • Order modifications ARE permitted during that window: adjusting stop loss, modifying take profit and cancelling orders.
  • Positions or limit orders placed more than 5 minutes before the release (with SL and TP set) may remain open or be triggered during the event.
  • Restricted releases: CPI, FOMC statement and meetings, Non-Farm Payrolls and USD PMI. Red folder events restrict every pair involving that currency and any index priced in it.
  • News source: Forex Factory.
  • The News Rule does NOT apply to QT ONE, QT INSTANT, QT Power or QT 1 Step (BNPL) accounts.
Yes
Inactivity Rule
  • QT TWO: no inactivity rule
  • QT INSTANT, QT Power, QT 1 Step (BNPL): 14 days
  • QT ONE: the comparison table states 7 days while the plan article states 14 days; confirm with support before relying on it.
    The period runs from the purchase date if no trade has been placed, or from the most recent closed trade.

35 consecutive calendar days without a trade closes the account automatically. Warning email sent 7 days before expiration.

Consistency Rule
Yes
  • QT INSTANT: 30%
  • QT Power: 35% in both evaluation and funded
  • QT 1 Step (BNPL): 20%
  • QT ONE, QT TWO: no consistency rule
Limited

Consistency is checked at payout and does not breach the account:

  • 20% Best Day Rule: current Classic, Legacy and Turbo challenges, Vanguard, Oracle and Ember
    The Best Day cycle resets after each successful payout.
  • Horizon and Odyssey: no consistency or Best Day Rule in evaluation or funded accounts.
Hold Weekend
Yes
Yes
Prohibited Strategies
  • All-or-Nothing
  • Latency Trading
  • Arbitrage Trading
  • High-Frequency Trading
  • Tick scalping
  • Reverse Trading or Group Hedging
  • Order book spamming
  • Flooding the server with messages due to incorrect use of algorithm
  • One side betting
  • Trading behaviours that the Risk Department deem Toxic
  • Emulators, and running the same EA with the same settings as other traders to produce identical trades.
  • Tick scalping (trades held under 2 minutes on Oracle) and high-frequency trading (HFT).
  • Martingale, grid trading, one-sided bets, reverse trading and hedging (also within the same account).
  • News straddling (bracket orders placed around economic releases).
  • Signal services and copying trades from other people's accounts.
  • Team/group trading or executing identical trades across accounts to bypass the $1.5M cap.
  • Sharing passwords, account access or identity (KYC).
  • Exploiting platform bugs, delays or pricing errors.
  • Opening multiple user profiles (One Person, One Account policy).
  • Splitting trades intentionally to bypass the 20% Best Day Rule.
Free newsletter

Pick your firms. Get what matters.

  • Exclusive promotions, updated daily
  • Funded trading industry news
  • Full control: you choose which firms to follow

FreeNo spamOne-click unsubscribe

Community

Join the community

Join us on our mission to become the most influential family in funded trading.

  • trade-ideasTrading ideas from the community
  • giveawaysGiveaways from prop firms
  • respect-leaderboardTop 10 by Respect earned
  • wins-and-lossesFundings, payouts and blown accounts
Join the Discord